01Facts
The plaintiffs (Plaintiff No. 1, son; Plaintiff No. 2, mother) sued in O.S. No. 5827/2022 for cancellation of a registered sale deed dated 04.05.2020 executed by Defendant No. 1 (father/husband) in favour of Defendant No. 2 over the 'B' schedule property, and for declarations that an unregistered General Power of Attorney dated 28.10.2019 was null and void.
¶ 4Plaintiffs also sought permanent injunctions against alienation and interference with possession.
¶ 4Along with the plaint, the plaintiffs filed I.A. No. 1 under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 r/w Section 151 CPC seeking a temporary injunction against alienation pending suit.
¶ 5Defendant No. 1 did not file objections. Defendant No. 2, the purchaser, contested the application.
¶ 6The trial court held that no prima facie case was made out and dismissed I.A. No. 1.
¶ 6Plaintiffs contended that the power of attorney was unregistered and concocted, and that Plaintiff No. 1 learnt of the sale only in September 2022, after which a police complaint was lodged.
¶ 7–8A succession certificate in P&SC No. 267/2015 was granted on 06.03.2017 to Plaintiff No. 2 in respect of the 50% share of her deceased son in the 'B' schedule property.
¶ 8, 13Defendant No. 2 stated during arguments that he had bequeathed the property to his son due to ill health and that neither he nor the donee would alienate it pending suit.
¶ 10–11, 1402Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court's refusal to grant a temporary injunction against alienation of the 'B' schedule property, in the face of the plaintiffs' claimed interest under the succession certificate, is perverse and calls for interference in appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(r) CPC.
¶ 12ii.2. Whether a non-alienation undertaking given before the appellate court by the purchaser (Defendant No. 2) is a sufficient substitute for a temporary injunction, and whether the injunction should issue against the donee/son.
¶ 14, 16–1703Law Applied
Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 r/w Section 151 CPC permit a temporary injunction to preserve property pending suit, and the trial court must examine three requirements: prima facie case, balance of convenience, and hardship or irreparable injury to each party.
¶ 15Order XLIII Rule 1(r) CPC is the basis for appellate interference with an order refusing an injunction.
caption · ¶ 16The trial court must consider the materials placed before it, and a statement made at the bar of the appellate court is not a substitute for that consideration.
¶ 14A court may take steps to avoid multiplicity of proceedings by preserving the subject matter pending adjudication.
¶ 15No precedents are cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The trial court overlooked the succession certificate in P&SC No. 267/2015, which, along with the relationship of the parties and the admitted registered sale, was material to the plaintiffs' claim to a right in the property.
¶ 13, 15Because Plaintiff No. 2 had not joined in the sale, her claimed share was a matter requiring adjudication at trial, and the trial court could not ignore the need to preserve the property to avoid multiplicity of proceedings.
¶ 15The court treated the finding of "no prima facie case" as perverse and arbitrary.
¶ 16The defendant's undertaking was given only at the appellate stage and did not replace the trial court's duty to examine the record.
¶ 14The non-grant of interim relief had already led to a gift deed in favour of the son, which reinforced the need for an injunction binding that transferee.
¶ 15Since the plaintiffs sought only a restraint on alienation and not mandatory relief, the balance of convenience and hardship favoured the plaintiffs.
¶ 16–1705Holding
The trial court's refusal to grant a temporary injunction is perverse and calls for interference. The appellate court's holding is limited to the non-alienation order; the substantive questions on the sale deed and power of attorney remain for trial.
¶ 7, 16–17The appeal is allowed, the order dated 16.12.2024 on I.A. No. 1 is set aside, and I.A. No. 1 is allowed. A temporary injunction is granted restraining the donee/son of Defendant No. 2 from alienating, transferring, or creating third-party rights or charges over the 'B' schedule property until disposal of the suit. Pending applications are disposed of as insignificant.
¶ 17, Order cl. 1–4Original Court PDF
SRI VISHNU MOHAN NAIDUvsV HARI MOHAN NAIDU
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
