01Facts
Ram Pal (respondent) has worked as a Chowkidar/Watchman at a Youth Hostel since 2002.
¶ 9When he sought regularization, the petitioners (Union of India) rejected the claim and terminated his services.
¶ 6 · ¶ 14He filed an Original Application before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Chandigarh Bench (Circuit Bench, Shimla), No. OA 063/00534/2017.
The Tribunal upheld the rejection of regularization but quashed the termination order. It directed that he continue in service on existing terms until a post became available for considering his regularization.
¶ 6–7The Tribunal relied on the Principal Bench decision in Gopal Singh and noted that, although no Chowkidar post existed, the respondent was working against clerical posts and the work existed, which the respondent's rejoinder asserted and the petitioners had not denied by counter.
¶ 6The petitioners challenged this order in writ, contending that (i) the State of Himachal Pradesh was a necessary party not impleaded; (ii) the Youth Hostel must generate its own resources and cannot pay salary; and (iii) the Hostel is unsafe, abandoned, and needs no Chowkidar.
¶ 2–4The respondent was continuing in service pursuant to the Tribunal's order and was being paid daily wages.
¶ 9–1002Issues
i.1. Whether the Original Application was bad for non-joinder of the State of Himachal Pradesh as a necessary party.
¶ 2, 7, 14ii.2. Whether the Tribunal's direction to continue the respondent in service on existing terms, while upholding the denial of regularization, is sustainable in the face of the petitioners' contentions regarding the Hostel's finances, condition, and need for a Chowkidar.
¶ 3–4, 8, 11–1303Law Applied
Necessary-party principle: a party is necessary only if it has control, ownership, or an employer-employee relationship with the claimant.
¶ 14Limited scope of interference with a Tribunal's findings: the High Court interferes only where the findings are perverse or contrary to the record.
¶ 12Gopal Singh (Principal Bench, CAT), as relied upon by the Tribunal, holds that a claimant denied regularization for want of a post may nonetheless be continued where the work exists.
¶ 6The employer bears responsibility for maintaining or repairing its premises, and the employee cannot be made to bear that burden.
¶ 1404Reasoning
On the necessary-party objection, the Court found no material showing State control or ownership of the Youth Hostel. The petitioners' own conduct, in rejecting regularization and terminating services, established that the employer-employee relationship, if any, lay with them alone. The State was therefore neither necessary nor proper.
¶ 14The petitioners had not sought a stay during the pendency of the writ, which would have been the natural step if no work existed. This implied that work was available, and the respondent had been performing it since 2002.
¶ 9The Tribunal's direction was innocuous: it did not grant regularization but only ensured continuation of work already being done, until a post became available.
¶ 11, 13The petitioners could not show that the Tribunal's findings were perverse.
¶ 12The contention on the Hostel's finances and dilapidated state was rejected because maintenance and funding of the premises are the employer's responsibility, not the employee's.
¶ 1405Holding
The Original Application was not bad for non-joinder, as the State of Himachal Pradesh was neither a necessary nor a proper party.
¶ 14The Tribunal's order, which upheld denial of regularization but directed continuation in service on existing terms until a post became available, was innocuous and did not call for interference.
¶ 11–13The writ petition was dismissed as devoid of merit, and pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of accordingly.
¶ 14The respondent's continued engagement and daily-wage payment under the Tribunal's order therefore stand.
¶ 10, 14Original Court PDF
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERSvsRAM PAL
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
