01Facts
The petitioner, a Turner diploma holder, was engaged as a daily-wage Mechanic-cum-Fitter with the HPPWD, Chamba, from 1974.
¶ 2, 9, 13On the DPC's recommendation of 28.06.1978, he was regularized on 30.06.1978 in the pay scale of Rs. 100-160.
¶ 2, 9The petitioner claims he is the senior-most Mechanic-cum-Fitter and should be placed in the Rs. 4550-7220 scale from 01.01.1996, following the 1997 and 1998 Notifications, which placed skilled categories in three grades (Junior Technician, Technician Grade-III, Technician Grade-II) in a 50:30:20 ratio.
¶ 3, 4, 5The respondents' 21.09.2010 rejection order (Annexure P-15) treated Shri Pritam Singh (joined 11.07.1978) as senior, and placed the petitioner in the Rs. 4020-6200 scale.
¶ 6The combined seniority list shows juniors, including S/Sh. Satish Kumar, Mahima Nand and Atma Ram, placed in the Rs. 4550-7220 scale.
¶ 7, 14, 16The respondents contended that the petitioner lacked the Motor Mechanic qualification required under the R&P Rules, and that his pay scale was not a promotion.
¶ 6, 9, 10The respondents later granted him the Rs. 4550-7220 scale (re-designated Technician Grade-I) with effect from 01.10.2012.
¶ 9, 1402Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner, regularized on 30.06.1978 and in service since 1974, is junior to Shri Pritam Singh merely on the basis of joining date (11.07.1978 vs. 12.07.1978).
¶ 13ii.2. Whether the placement of the petitioner in the lower pay scale (Rs. 4020-6200) under the 50:30:20 cadre ratio, which is contingent on educational qualification under the R&P Rules, was lawful.
¶ 15, 19iii.3. Whether denial of the Rs. 4550-7220 scale to the petitioner, while his juniors were granted it, is arbitrary and discriminatory.
¶ 16, 18, 20iv.4. Whether the petitioner is entitled to the higher scale with effect from 01.01.1996 and consequential benefits.
¶ 1, 2103Law Applied
The Notification dated 01.09.1998, which amended the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1998, prescribes the 50:30:20 distribution of Junior Technician, Technician Grade-III and Technician Grade-II (Rs. 4550-7220) scales, based on cadre strength and seniority rather than qualification.
¶ 4, 13, 15, 19The Notification dated 30.08.1997 designated skilled posts as Junior Technician with trade specifications in brackets.
¶ 3A senior cannot be paid a lesser salary than a junior, as drawn from Gurcharan Singh Grewal v. Punjab State Electricity Board, (2009) 3 SCC 94, and Union of India v. C.R. Madhava Murthy, (2022) 6 SCC 183.
¶ 17, 18The respondents' reliance on the qualification requirements of the R&P Rules was rejected as not reflected in the 1998 Notification.
¶ 1904Reasoning
The court held that the petitioner's regularization on 30.06.1978, which the respondents admitted, along with his service since 1974, made the joining-date comparison with Pritam Singh irrelevant.
¶ 13Because the 1998 Notification allocates scales by seniority within the cadre, the petitioner's seniority as a Junior Technician was the operative criterion, and the Rs. 4550-7220 scale could not be withheld on the ground of qualification.
¶ 15, 19The respondents admitted that juniors, namely Satish Kumar, Mahima Nand and Atma Ram, were granted the higher scale from 01.01.1996 or 01.08.2004.
¶ 14, 16Relying on Gurcharan Singh Grewal and C.R. Madhava Murthy, the court held that denying the petitioner the same scale while his juniors received it was arbitrary and discriminatory.
¶ 16, 18, 20The court set aside the rejection order and found the petitioner entitled to the higher scale from 01.01.1996.
¶ 20, 2105Holding
The petitioner could not be treated as junior to Pritam Singh on the basis of joining date, the 1998 Notification's scale allocation is not contingent on qualification, and the denial of the Rs. 4550-7220 scale to a senior when juniors received it was arbitrary.
¶ 13, 15, 19, 20The petition was partly allowed. The order dated 21.09.2010 (Annexure P-15) was quashed and set aside. The respondents were directed to grant the petitioner the Rs. 4550-7220 scale with effect from 01.01.1996 with all consequential benefits, except monetary benefits, which are limited to three years before institution of the petition. If arrears are not paid within three months, interest at 6% per annum is payable from the date of judgment until actual payment. No costs were awarded.
¶ 21Original Court PDF
Narinder SinghvsSTATE OF HP
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
