Himachal Pradesh High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Himachal Pradesh HC Quashes ASI’s Suspension, Orders Him To Join Transfer Post As Senior Officer Had Kept Relieving On Hold

PUNEET SHARMAv.THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS

Himachal Pradesh HC Quashes ASI’s Suspension, Orders Him To Join Transfer Post As Senior Officer Had Kept Relieving On Hold. PUNEET SHARMA vs THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS. Himachal Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

Whether the petitioner’s suspension was justified on the grounds that he had not joined his transferred station and that a co-employee had complained against him.

The court held

The Court allowed the petition to the extent of quashing and setting aside the suspension order dated 20 July 2026.

It also directed

It directed the respondents to permit the petitioner to join at the transferred station in accordance with the transfer order dated 24 June 2026, while leaving him at liberty to pursue any surviving grievances through appropriate remedies.

01Facts

The petitioner, an Assistant Sub-Inspector posted in the TTR Wing at Shimla, was transferred to the 4th IRBn, Jangalberi, by order dated 24 June 2026.

He sought cancellation of the transfer on personal and service-related grounds; his immediate controlling officer recommended cancellation and kept his relieving pending while the representation awaited decision.

¶ 2(ii)–2(iii), 4(iii)

On 20 July 2026, the Director General of Police suspended him, citing both his failure to join at the transferred station and a co-employee’s complaint alleging harassment and influence over the co-employee’s deployment.

¶ 2(iv)

The controlling officer subsequently reported that the petitioner had not been relieved and denied that the petitioner influenced the co-employee’s deployment.

¶ 2(v), 4(iv)

The petitioner challenged the suspension and related orders by writ petition. During the proceedings, the respondents produced an order appointing an inquiry officer, although no charge-sheet had been issued.

¶ 3, 4(v)

02Issues

i.Whether the petitioner’s suspension was justified on the grounds that he had not joined his transferred station and that a co-employee had complained against him.

¶ 4(iii)–4(iv)

ii.Whether the suspension and subsequent inquiry steps were consistent with the governing principles for suspension and the requirements of fair disciplinary procedure.

¶ 4(ii), 4(v)

03Law Applied

In Union of India v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal, (2013) 16 SCC 147, the Supreme Court held that suspension must not be arbitrary, mala fide, or imposed as a routine measure; the authority must consider the gravity of the alleged misconduct, the available material, and whether the employee’s continued presence could prejudice the inquiry or public interest. Suspension is ordinarily justified where a strong prima facie case exists and the alleged misconduct, if proved, could warrant a major penalty.

¶ 4(ii)

State of Orissa v. Bimal Kumar Mohanty, (1994) 4 SCC 126, likewise requires the disciplinary authority to apply its mind to the nature and gravity of the allegations and the evidence, rather than suspend automatically.

¶ 4(ii)

The Court also stated that proceeding with an inquiry and appointing an inquiry officer before issuing a charge-sheet and giving the employee an opportunity to respond was inconsistent with natural justice and settled service jurisprudence.

¶ 4(v)

04Reasoning

The Court found that the petitioner’s non-joining could not fairly be attributed solely to him: his controlling officer had recommended cancellation of the transfer and had withheld the steps needed to relieve him pending consideration of the representation.

¶ 4(iii)

Nor did the co-employee’s complaint justify suspension, because the controlling officer stated that the deployment decision was his own and that the petitioner had exercised no influence over it.

¶ 4(iv)

The respondents also did not demonstrate how the petitioner’s continued service would prejudice an inquiry or otherwise warrant suspension.

¶ 4(iii)

The Court further noted that no charge-sheet had been issued, yet an inquiry officer had been appointed.

¶ 4(v)

Applying the principles governing suspension, it concluded that the suspension was uncalled for.

¶ 4(iii)–4(v)

05Holding

The Court allowed the petition to the extent of quashing and setting aside the suspension order dated 20 July 2026.

¶ 5

It directed the respondents to permit the petitioner to join at the transferred station in accordance with the transfer order dated 24 June 2026, while leaving him at liberty to pursue any surviving grievances through appropriate remedies.

¶ 5
Himachal Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

PUNEET SHARMAvsTHE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS

Himachal Pradesh High Court · November 03, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment