01Facts
The three petitioners hold Bachelor of Dental Surgery (BDS) degrees. Pursuant to an advertisement dated 08.03.2018 for the post of Dental Hygienist, which listed BDS as a qualification, they were appointed on a contractual basis by order dated 21.08.2018.
¶ 3, 5The petitioners have since worked as Dental Hygienists for about five years.
¶ 3The respondent Department advertised the post of Dental Technician on 13.06.2023 under the Rajasthan Medical and Health Subordinate Service Rules, 1965 ("Rules of 1965"), as amended in 2013. The prescribed qualification is "Secondary or its equivalent with 2 years certificate course of dental hygienist/dental mechanic recognized by Dental Council of India or from Institute recognized by Government." BDS does not appear in the list.
¶ 5.1The petitioners' candidature for the post of Dental Technician was not considered.
¶ 5.1The petitioners sought: (a) quashing of the note requiring registration with the Rajasthan Paramedical Council; (b) a declaration that BDS holders are eligible for Dental Technician; (c) inclusion of BDS in the 2013 Rules and the 2023 advertisement; (d) experience certificates for bonus marks; (e) a declaration of eligibility; and (f) acceptance of offline applications.
¶ 2The petitioners argued that the duties of the two posts are nearly identical and that BDS is a higher qualification.
¶ 3, 5.2The respondents contended that the Rules of 1965 do not recognise BDS for the post. They further argued that the Rajasthan Contractual Hiring to Civil Posts Rules, 2022 operate in a separate sphere and cannot be equated with the substantive recruitment rules.
¶ 4, 702Issues
i.1. Whether a candidate holding a higher qualification (BDS) is eligible for appointment to the post of Dental Technician when the applicable statutory Rules of 1965 prescribe a different qualification.
¶ 5.2, 6.6ii.2. Whether the Court can add BDS to the prescribed eligibility criteria or treat it as equivalent to the prescribed qualification.
¶ 6, 6.1, 6.5, 8iii.3. Whether the benefit of contractual employment under the Rules of 2022 requires inclusion of BDS in the eligibility criteria for Dental Technician under the Rules of 1965.
¶ 703Law Applied
Prescribing eligibility qualifications is within the exclusive domain of the employer or rule-making authority, and classification by educational qualification is valid under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, relying on State of J&K v. Triloki Nath Khosa, (1974) 1 SCC 19 and Mohammad Shujat Ali v. Union of India, (1975) 3 SCC 76.
¶ 6A higher qualification is not by itself an equivalent of the prescribed qualification, and courts cannot add to or substitute essential qualifications, as applied in Yogesh Kumar v. Government of NCT of Delhi, (2003) 3 SCC 548; Jyoti K.K. v. Kerala PSC, (2010) 15 SCC 596; Zahoor Ahmad Rather v. Sheikh Imtiyaz Ahmad, (2019) 2 SCC 404; and Maharashtra PSC v. Sandeep Shriram Warade, (2019) 6 SCC 362.
¶ 6.1Exclusion of over-qualified candidates must be assessed case by case, having regard to the rules, the nature of duties, and the employer's need for the right person, and no universal rule prefers higher qualifications, as held in Jomon K.K. v. Shajimon P., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 711.
¶ 36, 6.2Posts may be confined to candidates holding the prescribed qualification as a reasonable policy, as recognised in General Manager (HR) v. K. Poovarasan, 2026 INSC 581.
¶ 9-10, 6.3Equivalence of qualifications is for the recruiting authority and not the Court, as held by the Division Bench in Ramesh Chandra v. State of Rajasthan, D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 446/2020.
¶ 9-12, 6.5The Rajasthan Contractual Hiring to Civil Posts Rules, 2022, framed on 11.01.2022 for contractual posts not covered by other service rules, have no bearing on the eligibility criteria of a distinct post under the Rules of 1965.
¶ 704Reasoning
The petitioners' BDS qualification was accepted for the Dental Hygienist post in 2018, but the 2013 amendment to the Rules of 1965 prescribes a different qualification for Dental Technician, which omits BDS.
¶ 5, 5.1Dental Hygienist and Dental Technician are distinct posts with separate eligibility criteria, so BDS cannot be carried over from one to the other.
¶ 5.2Applying Jomon K.K. and Poovarasan, the rule-making authority deliberately reserved the Dental Technician post for holders of a two-year certificate course, not BDS holders.
¶ 6.4The petitioners' argument that a higher qualification should suffice was rejected, since the Court cannot treat a higher qualification as equivalent to the prescribed one.
¶ 6.1, 6.6Under Ramesh Chandra, the Court held that it could not declare BDS equivalent for recruitment purposes.
¶ 6.5, 6.6The State's earlier inclusion of BDS for the Hygienist post under a 2018 advertisement cannot be extended to a different post governed by different Rules.
¶ 6.6The contractual framework under the Rules of 2022 does not incorporate BDS into the 1965 Rules.
¶ 7Because the eligibility challenge failed, the consequential reliefs (bonus marks, offline applications, and declaration of eligibility) were not separately addressed and fall with the dismissal.
¶ 8, 905Holding
BDS, though a higher qualification, does not make the petitioners eligible for Dental Technician when the Rules of 1965 prescribe a different qualification, and the Court cannot add BDS to the eligibility criteria or declare it equivalent.
¶ 6.6, 8The Court declined to include BDS in the Rules of 1965 or the 2023 advertisement and found that the Rules of 2022 do not alter this position.
¶ 7, 8The writ petition, being devoid of merit, was dismissed in its entirety. Prayers (a) through (h) stand rejected by necessary implication.
¶ 9Original Court PDF
DR. DIGVIJAY SINGH PANWARvsTHE STATE OF RAJASTHAN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
