Karnataka High CourtTax LawConstitutional Law

Karnataka HC Bars M-Sand Trader From Reopening 14.5% Tax Rate After Karasamadhana Scheme Settlement

M/S. MEENAXI BUILDING SOLUTIONS PVT.LTDv.JOINT COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES

Karnataka HC Bars M-Sand Trader From Reopening 14.5% Tax Rate After Karasamadhana Scheme Settlement. M/S. MEENAXI BUILDING SOLUTIONS PVT.LTD vs JOINT COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether a dealer who has availed the benefit of the Karasamadhana Scheme, 2019 and paid the assessed tax is precluded from seeking rectification of, or appealing against, the assessment order on the rate of tax.

The court held

Having availed the benefit of the Karasamadhana Scheme, 2019 and paid the assessed tax, the petitioner was barred under Clause 5.6 from challenging or seeking rectification of the assessment, and Article 265 did not revive that challenge because the dispute concerned only the rate, not the levy.

It also directed

The court concurred with the KAT's decision and dismissed the STRP as unmerited, upholding the KAT's order dated 04.09.2026 in ST Appeal No. 85 of 2023.

01Facts

The petitioner, a registered dealer under the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (KVAT Act), traded in cement aggregates and GGBS. For FY 2014-15 it paid tax on M-sand at 5.5% under Entry 83 of the Third Schedule ("Sand and Grits").

¶ 2

The Adjudicating Authority (Respondent No. 2) held that M-sand attracted 14.5% under the residuary entry and, by assessment order dated 27.02.2019, raised a differential tax of ₹3,45,348, penalty of ₹34,535, and interest of ₹2,44,510.

¶ 2

While the demand was pending, the Karasamadhana Scheme, 2019 (the Scheme) was introduced. The petitioner applied on 30.09.2019, paid the differential tax, and obtained waiver of penalty and interest.

¶ 3

Thereafter, the petitioner filed a rectification application relying on Robo Silicon Private Limited v. State of Karnataka (STRP No. 24/2019, decided 23.09.2021) to contend M-sand was taxable at 5.5%. The rectification was rejected by endorsement dated 21.12.2022.

¶ 4

The Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal on 06.10.2023 on the ground that the petitioner, having availed the Scheme, could not challenge the assessment.

¶ 5

The Karnataka Appellate Tribunal (KAT) dismissed the further appeal in ST Appeal No. 85 of 2023 by order dated 04.09.2026 on the same grounds.

¶ 5

The petitioner filed the present STRP under Section 65(1) of the KVAT Act.

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether a dealer who has availed the benefit of the Karasamadhana Scheme, 2019 and paid the assessed tax is precluded from seeking rectification of, or appealing against, the assessment order on the rate of tax.

¶ 6 · ¶ 9–11, 13

ii.2. Whether the collection of tax at 14.5% on M-sand, as assessed, is without authority of law in violation of Article 265 of the Constitution of India, thereby permitting the petitioner to challenge the assessment notwithstanding the Scheme.

¶ 6 · ¶ 12

03Law Applied

The court relied on the terms of the Karasamadhana Scheme, 2019, under which the taxpayer, on paying the assessed tax, obtains waiver of penalty and interest and settlement of the assessment issues.

¶ 8

Clause 5.6 of the Scheme bars a dealer, after applying for or availing its benefits, from filing any appeal or application before an appellate authority or court, or seeking rectification of orders.

¶ 9–10

The court treated Clause 5.6 as unambiguous and as attaching finality to the assessment upon payment.

¶ 11

Article 265 of the Constitution mandates that no tax be levied or collected except by authority of law. The court distinguished between the levy of tax (authorised by the KVAT Act) and the rate of tax; a dispute only as to rate does not render the levy unauthorised once the dispute has attained finality.

¶ 12

The petitioner's reliance on Robo Silicon (STRP No. 24/2019) was noted as the basis for its rate challenge, but the court did not rest its reasoning on that decision.

¶ 4, 6

Provisions in the judgment · 2

Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 Section 65Section 63

04Reasoning

The court held that the petitioner had obtained the Scheme's benefit of waiver of penalty and interest, which was conditional on paying the assessed tax and accepting the assessment as final.

¶ 8, 11

Since the petitioner had availed the Scheme, Clause 5.6 expressly foreclosed its later rectification application and appeals, and the court found no ambiguity in that bar.

¶ 9–11

The petitioner's argument that the Scheme should not apply where assessed tax far exceeded the correct tax was rejected, as the court treated the bargain as one of finality irrespective of the merits of the rate.

¶ 6, 11

On Article 265, the court held that the levy was admittedly under the KVAT Act and the dispute concerned only the rate; once the dispute had attained finality through the Scheme, the tax could not be impugned as being without authority of law.

¶ 12

The court did not engage with the merits of the rate issue or with whether Robo Silicon would have governed the outcome absent the Scheme, and the reasoning rests on the Scheme's finality clause.

¶ 11–13

05Holding

Having availed the benefit of the Karasamadhana Scheme, 2019 and paid the assessed tax, the petitioner was barred under Clause 5.6 from challenging or seeking rectification of the assessment, and Article 265 did not revive that challenge because the dispute concerned only the rate, not the levy.

¶ 11–13

The court concurred with the KAT's decision and dismissed the STRP as unmerited, upholding the KAT's order dated 04.09.2026 in ST Appeal No. 85 of 2023.

¶ 13–14
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

M/S. MEENAXI BUILDING SOLUTIONS PVT.LTDvsJOINT COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES

Karnataka High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment