01Facts
The Assistant Commissioner passed an Order-in-Original dated 28.12.2023 demanding tax, interest and penalty totalling ₹34,14,890 for AY 2017-18
¶ 2The order was communicated the same day
¶ 3The petitioner filed the first appeal (Form GST APL-01) on 02.07.2024, 187 days beyond the three-month limit under Section 107(1)
¶ 2–3The Joint Commissioner (Appeals) rejected the appeal solely for delay, holding that Section 107(4) permits condonation of at most one further month and that it therefore lacked jurisdiction
¶ 3That rejection order dated 13.07.2026 (Appeal No. GST-440/2024-25) is impugned
¶ 1, 17The petitioner argued that the statutory appeal should not be defeated on a technicality, that the appeal should be heard on merits, and relied on W.P. No. 107961/2026 and Bondada Engineering Ltd. v. Office of the Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax (W.P. No. 26900/2024, decided 20.03.2025)
¶ 5–8The learned AGA contended that the appellate authority is a statutory creature bound by the 30-day maximum condonable period, that the delay was attributable to the assessee, and sought costs to deter such litigants
¶ 9–1202Issues
i.1. Whether the appellate authority was justified in rejecting the first appeal as time-barred, the delay (187 days) exceeding the one-month condonable period under Section 107(4) of the KGST/CGST Act, 2017
¶ 9–10, 16ii.2. Whether, notwithstanding the delay, the petitioner must be afforded an opportunity to contest the tax liability on merits, and if so, on what conditions
¶ 13–1403Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 107(1) of the KGST/CGST Act, 2017, which allows an appeal within three months of communication of the order, and Section 107(4), which permits condonation of a further one-month delay as recorded by the appellate authority
¶ 3, 9It applied Section 107(11) and (12), which require the appellate authority to frame points for determination, decide them on merits, and record reasons in writing
¶ 6, 15–16It relied on the principle of audi alteram partem and the view that denial of a statutory appellate remedy amounts to denial of a substantive right
¶ 5–7, 15It followed the binding coordinate-bench approach in Bondada Engineering Ltd. (W.P. No. 26900/2024), which remitted matters to the appellate authority for fresh consideration in the interest of justice, and the ruling in W.P. No. 107961/2026, which applied the same approach
¶ 8, 15Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA GOODS AND SERVICES TAX ACT, 2017 Section 107
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 Section 107
04Reasoning
The Court accepted that the appellate authority is a statutory body and that the delay exceeded the one-month condonable period
¶ 9–10However, it noted that the appeal was rejected only on limitation and never on merits
¶ 13Because the tax liability is substantial, and the statutory remedy under Section 107 is the petitioner's primary forum for contesting it, the Court held that the petitioner should be heard on merits
¶ 14Following Bondada and W.P. No. 107961/2026, the Court condoned the 187-day delay in the exercise of its writ jurisdiction and remitted the matter
¶ 8, 15, 17(ii)–(iv)To address the assessee-attributable delay and the State's burden in such cases, the Court made relief conditional: deposit of an additional 10% of the tax liability before the appellate authority and payment of ₹50,000 costs to the Pradhan Mantri Emergency Relief Fund, both within two weeks, with proof to be filed before the Court and the appellate authority
¶ 14, 17(iv)–(vi)The Court also directed that the appellate authority decide the appeal strictly under Section 107(11) and (12) within two months of the petitioner's first appearance on 10.12.2026
¶ 15(vi), 17(vii)–(viii)05Holding
The Court held that the appellate authority's rejection solely on the ground of delay, without adjudicating the merits, could not stand
¶ 17The writ petition is allowed. The 187-day delay is condoned. The order dated 13.07.2026 in Appeal No. GST-440/2024-25 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) to give the petitioner a reasonable opportunity to make his case and to decide the appeal on merits under Section 107(11) and (12)
¶ 17(i)–(iv)Relief is subject to: (a) deposit of an additional 10% of the tax liability and (b) payment of ₹50,000 costs to the PMERF within two weeks, with acknowledgments filed before the Court and the appellate authority; these are conditions precedent to consideration on merits
¶ 17(iv)–(vi)The petitioner must appear before the appellate authority on 10.12.2026, and the appeal is to be disposed of within two months of first appearance. All rival contentions are left open
¶ 17(vii)–(ix)Original Court PDF
SRI SUNIL S/O JIVAPPA HANAMANNAVARvsTHE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL TAXES
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
