01Facts
The Assessing Officer (AO) passed an assessment order dated 29.12.2017 under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the Act) for AY 2015-16, adding ₹11,59,30,375 under Section 68 as an unexplained cash credit.
¶ 3The amount was an opening balance representing share application money pending allotment, received from director Sri B. Ravi Kumar Reddy. It equalled the closing balance for FY 2012-13 (AY 2013-14), where it appeared as an outstanding receipt in the final accounts as on 31.03.2013.
¶ 4The AO held that the amount was not received in FY 2012-13, as it did not match bank credits, and therefore treated the closing and opening balances as unexplained.
¶ 4The Assessee disputed this finding, but the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC) did not examine it.
¶ 5The Assessee also contended that the AO could not make an addition based on transactions of a prior year that were not under assessment in AY 2015-16.
¶ 6NFAC allowed the Assessee's appeal under Section 250.
¶ 2The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dismissed the Revenue's appeal, relying on CIT v. Sridev Enterprises, and disposed of the Assessee's cross-objection without examining it.
¶ 2, 7The Revenue appealed under Section 260A, with a delay of 636 days.
¶ 1, 1202Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal's order deleting the Section 68 addition of ₹11,59,30,375 for AY 2015-16 is perverse, given that the opening balance cannot be treated differently from the closing balance of the previous year.
¶ 8, Q.1ii.2. Whether the addition could be sustained for AY 2015-16 on the basis of an examination of FY 2012-13 transactions, which were not under assessment in that year.
¶ 6, 10–11iii.3. Whether the Revenue's remaining framed questions (alleged bogus transaction, failure to prove genuineness, mismatch of books and bank statements, and taxability of software licence receipts under Section 9(1)(vi)) raise any substantial question of law.
¶ 8, Qs. 2–5iv.4. Whether the appeal should be entertained despite a delay of 636 days.
¶ 1203Law Applied
Section 260A of the Act, under which an appeal lies only on a substantial question of law.
¶ 1, 13Section 68 of the Act, which permits addition of unexplained cash credits, and under which any such addition must be made in the assessment year corresponding to the previous year in which the credit appeared.
¶ 10The principle in CIT v. Sridev Enterprises (1991) 59 Taxman 439 (Kar.), which holds that the status of an outstanding amount on the first day of an accounting year is the same as on the last day of the previous year, so its nature cannot differ between the two. Consistency is required: where earlier assessments accepted an account's nature, the Revenue cannot take a contrary stand on those amounts without reopening the assessment.
¶ 9Provisions in the judgment · 5
Income Tax Act, 1961 Section 260ASection 250Section 143Section 68Section 9
04Reasoning
The AO's addition rested entirely on an examination of the FY 2012-13 records and a finding that the closing balance of 31.03.2013 was unexplained. Under Section 68, any such addition was required to be made in AY 2013-14, the year corresponding to that previous year, and not in AY 2015-16.
¶ 10Applying Sridev Enterprises, the opening balance for FY 2013-14 carried the same status as the closing balance for FY 2012-13, so it could not be treated as unexplained in a later year without reopening the earlier assessment.
¶ 9–10The Court did not decide the factual dispute over whether the amount was actually received, because the legal bar on the addition was sufficient.
¶ 5, 11The Court also did not address the software-licence royalty question (framed as Question 4), and the cross-objection was not considered.
¶ 2, 805Holding
No substantial question of law arises, because the addition under Section 68 could not be made in AY 2015-16 on the basis of an examination of FY 2012-13 and an unexplained credit in that year. The Court therefore held that NFAC and the ITAT were correct in concluding that the addition could not be made in AY 2015-16.
¶ 11The appeal was dismissed on the merits and also on the ground of the inordinate 636-day delay in filing.
¶ 12–13No separate orders were passed on the Assessee's cross-objection, which the ITAT had disposed of without examination.
¶ 2Original Court PDF
THE PR COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-2vsM/S M AND M EQUIPEMENTS PVT LTD
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
