01Facts
The petitioners, plaintiffs in O.S. No. 227/2021, sought production of loan files, insurance policies and account statements relating to two housing loans held by the deceased Kirankumar S. Neeravari.
pp. 2–5An earlier application seeking the documents from Punjab National Bank was allowed, but the Bank informed the petitioners that PNB Housing Finance Limited held the records.
pp. 2–5The trial court rejected a subsequent application seeking the same documents from that company, finding them unnecessary to a partition suit.
pp. 2–5The petitioners challenged that order under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
pp. 7–802Issues
i.1. Whether the trial court erred in rejecting the application for production of the loan and insurance records from PNB Housing Finance Limited, after allowing an earlier application for the same documents from Punjab National Bank.
pp. 7–8ii.2. Whether the impugned order warranted interference under the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction.
p. 803Law Applied
The application was made under Order XVI Rule 6 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
p. 2Order XVI Rule 6 enables a court to require production of documents by summons; Section 151 preserves the court’s inherent power to make orders necessary for the ends of justice.
pp. 7–8The Court relied on the trial court’s earlier finding that the documents were necessary to adjudicate the issues in the suit.
pp. 7–8No precedent was cited.
p. 2 · pp. 7–804Reasoning
The High Court noted that the later application sought the same documents as the application previously allowed; the only material change was the identity of the custodian, after Punjab National Bank stated that PNB Housing Finance Limited held the records.
pp. 7–8Since the trial court had already found those documents necessary to adjudicate the suit, it was unclear how they had become unnecessary merely because production was sought from the correct custodian.
pp. 7–8The Court held that the trial court’s contrary reasoning was perverse.
pp. 7–805Holding
The High Court allowed the writ petition, quashed the order rejecting the application, and directed the trial court to issue necessary directions to PNB Housing Finance Limited to furnish the documents sought by the petitioners.
p. 8Original Court PDF
RENUKA W/O SHANKAR ALIAS SHNAKARAPPA ALIAS SHANKRAPPA ALIAS SHANKARANNA NEERAVARIvsVIJAYLAXMI W/O KIRANKUMAR NEERAVARI
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
