01Facts
The petitioner claimed a share in property that was the subject of a pending partition suit, O.S. No. 1036/2012. In that suit, an injunction restraining alienation of the property had been granted and confirmed. The property was also subject to an earlier agreement of sale and a compromise in proceedings under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; after the compromise terms were not fulfilled, execution proceedings were initiated and a sale deed was executed.
pp. 6–7, paras 5–7In the execution proceedings, the petitioner filed applications under Section 47 and Order XXI Rules 55 and 26 of the CPC. The Executing Court rejected them, and the petitioner challenged that common order by writ petition.
pp. 2–4, paras 1–2.302Issues
i.1. Whether the Executing Court was justified in rejecting the petitioner’s Section 47 CPC application seeking adjudication of her rights in the property, where an identical claim was pending in a separate partition suit
p. 7, para 8ii.2. Whether the Executing Court was justified in rejecting the application under Order XXI Rule 55 CPC to remove an attachment
p. 7, para 9iii.3. Whether the Executing Court should have stayed execution under Order XXI Rule 26 CPC pending disposal of the partition suit
pp. 7–8, para 1003Law Applied
Section 47 CPC provides for determination by the executing court of questions arising between the parties to the suit, or their representatives, relating to execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree. Order XXI Rule 55 CPC concerns removal of an attachment in the circumstances provided by that rule, while Order XXI Rule 26 CPC empowers a court to stay execution in the circumstances specified therein.
The Court relied on the Co-ordinate Bench’s decision in R.F.A. No. 152/2003 (6 June 2006), applying its holding that a parallel application seeking identical relief or adjudication cannot be maintained where a separate suit seeking that relief is pending.
p. 7, para 8It also relied on the prior dismissal of the judgment-debtors’ stay request in W.P. No. 37762/2025.
p. 8, para 10Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 47
04Reasoning
The petitioner’s claim to a share in the property was already before the civil court in the pending partition suit. Applying R.F.A. No. 152/2003, the High Court held that the Executing Court was justified in declining to adjudicate the same claim through the Section 47 application.
p. 7, para 8The Rule 55 application was properly rejected because no attachment order had been brought to the Executing Court’s attention.
p. 7, para 9As to the Rule 26 application, an identical stay request had already been rejected in W.P. No. 37762/2025, and the Court found no basis to take a different view.
p. 8, para 10The petitioner’s concern that possession or development might alter the property and impair relief in the partition suit was considered premature; she remained at liberty to pursue appropriate remedies in that suit.
p. 8, para 1105Holding
The High Court dismissed the writ petition and declined to interfere with the Executing Court’s order rejecting the three applications.
p. 8, para 11The petitioner was left to pursue appropriate remedies in the pending partition suit.
p. 8, para 11Original Court PDF
SMT. H. S. DEVIKA RANIvsM/S. RENAISSANCE HOLDINGS AND DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD.,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
