01Facts
The petitioner filed O.S. No. 32/2008 for specific performance and later sought a declaration that sale deeds concerning the property were not binding on him.
pp. 3–4Defendant No. 4 was set ex parte, and an ex parte judgment and decree was passed on 18 August 2018.
pp. 3–4Defendant No. 4 applied under Order IX Rule 13 CPC to set it aside on 9 November 2018; the Trial Court allowed the application on 4 April 2026.
pp. 3–4The decree-holder challenged that order under Section 115 CPC.
pp. 3–4The petitioner contended that Defendant No. 4 had not established non-service or sufficient cause for his absence; Defendant No. 4 maintained that he resided in Kerala and sought an opportunity to contest the suit.
pp. 6–802Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court was justified in setting aside the ex parte decree under Order IX Rule 13 CPC without sufficient material establishing non-service of summons or sufficient cause for Defendant No. 4’s absence.
pp. 4, 8–9ii.2. Whether the impugned order should be set aside and the application remanded for fresh consideration.
pp. 9–1003Law Applied
Order IX Rule 13 CPC permits setting aside an ex parte decree where the defendant establishes that summons were not duly served or that sufficient cause prevented appearance.
pp. 5–6Under its second proviso, a decree cannot be set aside merely for irregularity in service where the defendant had notice of the hearing date and sufficient time to appear.
pp. 5–6The Court relied on Parimal v. Veena @ Bharti, Civil Appeal No. 1467 of 2011 (8 February 2011), which emphasizes these statutory requirements while recognizing that the Court’s approach may be liberal and elastic, but that relief cannot be granted outside the rule’s requirements.
pp. 5–6The revision was brought under Section 115 CPC.
p. 2Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 115
04Reasoning
The High Court observed that Defendant No. 4 had not placed sufficient material to substantiate his claimed residence in Kerala or otherwise establish that summons were not served; the Trial Court had accepted the assertions in his application without an adequate evidentiary basis.
pp. 8–10It therefore held that the ex parte decree could not be set aside routinely.
pp. 8–10However, balancing the parties’ interests, the Court considered it appropriate to give Defendant No. 4 an opportunity to place supporting material before the Trial Court, rather than determine the Order IX Rule 13 application finally in revision.
pp. 8–1005Holding
The High Court allowed the revision, set aside the Trial Court’s order dated 4 April 2026, and remanded Misc. No. 61/2018 for fresh consideration.
pp. 9–10Defendant No. 4 was directed to place all relevant material before the Trial Court; the parties were directed to appear there on 23 November 2026, and the Trial Court was directed to decide the application within three months thereafter.
pp. 9–10The High Court expressly stated that it had made no finding on the merits.
pp. 9–10Original Court PDF
A RAMAKRISHNAvsC BHASKARAN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
