01Facts
The plaintiffs (Respondents 1–6) sued Defendants 7 and 8 for partition and separate possession of their 3/4th share in the suit schedule property, and for a declaration that a sale deed dated 06.10.2008, executed by Defendant No. 1 in favour of Defendant No. 2, is not binding on them.
¶ 3Defendant No. 2 filed a written statement stating that the property was sold to the petitioner, but the sale deed was not registered due to technical problems. Defendant No. 2 had instead executed a general power of attorney (GPA) in the petitioner's favour.
¶ 4The petitioner, claiming to be GPA holder for consideration of Rs. 2,04,000 and in possession of the property, applied under Order I Rule 10(2) CPC (I.A. II) for impleadment as Defendant No. 3.
¶ 4The plaintiffs objected, contending that the suit concerns ancestral property, that alienees need not be impleaded in a preliminary decree, that Defendant No. 2 already represents the alleged purchaser's interest, and that a non-party cannot be added merely because he is incidentally affected.
¶ 5The Trial Court rejected I.A. II by order dated 13.08.2024 in O.S. No. 110/2016.
¶ 1, 6The petitioner challenged that order under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner, being the holder of a general power of attorney for consideration executed by Defendant No. 1, is a necessary and proper party to the suit for partition and requires impleadment under Order I Rule 10(2) CPC.
¶ 903Law Applied
The court applied Order I Rule 10(2) CPC, which governs the addition of parties.
¶ 1, 4It adopted the Supreme Court's test, as stated in Mumbai International Airport Pvt. Ltd. v. Regency Convention Centre and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. and Kasturi v. Iyyamperumal, that a necessary party is one against whom relief is sought and in whose absence no effective decree can be drawn, and a proper party is one whose presence enables the Court to adjudicate completely on the question involved.
¶ 11It further relied on the principle that the plaintiff is dominus litis and a person with no legal interest in the subject matter, or whose addition would introduce collateral disputes, cannot be added against the plaintiff's wish.
¶ 12The court also applied the principle that a GPA executed for consideration is not an instrument of transfer and conveys no title.
¶ 12Finally, it applied the rule that a preliminary decree declares shares without disturbing possession, and that equities of persons claiming under a co-sharer are worked out in final decree proceedings.
¶ 14The parties' cited authorities, S.K. Lakshminarasappa v. B. Rudraiah (ILR 2012 KAR 4129) and Basavanneppa Yallappa Angadi v. Shivappa Mallappa Hooli (W.P. No. 107569/2014), were noted in the arguments on the non-joinder of alienees and the impleadment of persons incidentally affected.
¶ 504Reasoning
The petitioner argued that the GPA and his possession made him a necessary party, since a partition decree would directly affect his rights.
¶ 7, 10The court rejected this. In a partition suit, the only necessary persons are the co-owners, whose shares are determined. The petitioner claimed no co-ownership, joint family status, or independent share. His claim derived solely from Defendant No. 2, who is already on record and fully competent to defend the claim on which the petitioner's rights rest.
¶ 12Because a GPA for consideration conveys no title, the petitioner had no right, title, or share in the property on which partition turns.
¶ 12Impleading him would also convert a simple partition suit into a dispute over the validity of the transaction between Defendants 2 and 3, a collateral controversy impermissible under Kasturi.
¶ 13On his grievance regarding possession, the court held that a preliminary decree only declares shares and does not disturb possession, so his equities could be addressed at the final decree stage.
¶ 1405Holding
The court held that the petitioner, as GPA holder of Defendant No. 2, is neither a necessary nor a proper party to the partition suit at this stage, and the point was answered in the negative.
¶ 15The writ petition was dismissed, and the Trial Court's order dated 13.08.2024 on I.A. II was affirmed.
¶ 16(i)–(ii)The petitioner may seek to work out any equities in the final decree proceedings, and all contentions on that aspect were left open.
¶ 16(ii)Original Court PDF
MALLIKARJUN ADOPTED S/O GADIGEPPA HUBBALLIvsPRAKASH ALIYAS PRAKASH GOUDA S/O SHANKAR ALIYAS SHANKARGOUDA MAREPPANAVAR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
