01Facts
The plaintiff filed O.S. No. 214/2021 for specific performance, relying on a registered agreement of sale dated 31.07.2017 executed by Defendant No. 1.
¶ 3Defendant No. 1 filed a written statement but thereafter remained absent.
¶ 4When the suit was posted for judgment, Respondent No. 2 (proposed Defendant No. 2) filed I.A. No. 5 under Order I Rule 10(2) read with Section 151 CPC.
¶ 4He claimed a registered agreement of sale dated 12.04.2017 executed in his favour by Defendant No. 1 without possession, alleged collusion between the plaintiff and Defendant No. 1, and contended that his presence was necessary for complete adjudication.
¶ 4The plaintiff objected to the application.
¶ 4The Trial Court allowed the application on 07.12.2024 and directed impleadment of proposed Defendant No. 2 as Defendant No. 2.
¶ 5The plaintiff challenged this order under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1, 502Issues
i.1. Whether the proposed Defendant No. 2, who claims under a separate agreement of sale with Defendant No. 1, is a necessary or proper party to a suit for specific performance between the plaintiff and Defendant No. 1.
¶ 6, 9ii.2. Whether impleadment at the stage when the suit is posted for judgment, which would widen the suit and delay proceedings, is permissible.
¶ 1003Law Applied
Order I Rule 10(2) CPC, which permits the addition of parties, and the test that a party is necessary if no effective decree can be drawn in its absence, as laid down in Kasturi v. Iyyamperumal (2005) 6 SCC 733.
¶ 9The doctrine of privity of contract, under which a stranger to the agreement acquires no right in a suit for its specific performance.
¶ 9The principle of dominus litis, under which the plaintiff, as master of the suit, cannot be compelled to add a stranger to the contract.
¶ 6, 9Mumbai International Airport Pvt. Ltd. v. Regency Convention Centre & Hotels Pvt. Ltd. (2010) 7 SCR 790, relied upon by the respondent for the proposition that a court may add a party at any stage if it is just and proper; the Court did not expressly discuss this authority.
¶ 7Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The suit, being for execution of an agreement between the plaintiff and Defendant No. 1, is governed by privity of contract, and proposed Defendant No. 2, who claims under a different agreement with Defendant No. 1, acquires no right, title or interest in the agreement sought to be enforced.
¶ 9Proposed Defendant No. 2 sought to join the suit instead of filing a fresh suit for enforcement of his own agreement, which the Court considered erroneous.
¶ 9Applying the Kasturi test, an effective decree could be drawn without proposed Defendant No. 2, so he was neither a necessary nor a proper party, and his impleadment would add complexity to the suit.
¶ 9The application was filed when the matter was posted for judgment, which would prejudice the plaintiff and unnecessarily delay proceedings.
¶ 1005Holding
Proposed Defendant No. 2 is neither a necessary nor a proper party, since an effective decree can be passed in his absence, and impleadment at the judgment stage would prejudice the plaintiff and delay the suit.
¶ 9, 10The writ petition is allowed, and the order dated 07.12.2024 on I.A. No. 5 in O.S. No. 214/2021 passed by the Civil Judge and JMFC, Navalgund, is set aside. The Court's reasoning implies that proposed Defendant No. 2's remedy lies in a separate suit against Defendant No. 1, though the operative order does not expressly so direct.
¶ 9, 11Original Court PDF
SRI. MALLIKARJUNSWAMI S/O KALLAYYA MATHAPATIvsSRI. PARASAPPA S/O SHIVAPPA NARAGUND
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
