01Facts
The plaintiffs (respondents 1 to 6) filed O.S. No. 8/2022 before the Additional Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Jamkhandi, seeking partition and separate possession of suit Schedule B properties.
¶ 3The suit was filed against 46 defendants, including the petitioner, defendant No. 10.
¶ 3The plaintiffs alleged that Sy. No. 465/1 was converted to non-agricultural use and that defendant Nos. 1 and 11 created a "Hakku Bitta Patra" dated 08.12.2011 in collusion with revenue officers.
¶ 5Defendant No. 10 pleaded that the land was relinquished to defendant Nos. 1 and 10 for development.
¶ 6A joint development agreement was executed with developer Mruthyunjaya (proposed defendant No. 47), under which the developer received 38% of commercial and 40% of residential plots, and the remaining plots were divided in six equal parts.
¶ 6Defendant No. 10 alleged that the plaintiffs obtained their plots and then filed the suit on a false claim.
¶ 7Defendant No. 10 filed I.A. No. 14 under Order I Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC to implead proposed defendant No. 47.
¶ 7The plaintiffs objected. Proposed defendant No. 47 appeared and objected to his impleadment.
¶ 8The trial court rejected I.A. No. 14 by order dated 21.09.2024.
¶ 9The petitioner challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
p. 102Issues
i.1. Whether the proposed defendant No. 47, a joint developer who is not a co-owner and against whom no relief is claimed, is a necessary or proper party to the suit for partition.
¶ 1203Law Applied
The court applied Order I Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC, under which the petitioner sought impleadment.
¶ 7A person becomes a necessary party where an effective decree cannot be drawn in his absence, as laid down in Kasturi v. Iyyamperumal, (2005) 6 SCC 733.
¶ 15The settled distinction between necessary and proper parties applies, under which a stranger who claims no share and against whom no relief is sought is neither necessary nor proper to a partition suit.
¶ 14The court's supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution was invoked to test the trial court's order.
p. 1Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The court first characterised proposed defendant No. 47 as a stranger to the co-ownership of the suit properties. He claimed no share, and no relief was sought against him. He had also disclaimed any need to be on record.
¶ 14Applying Kasturi, the court examined whether an effective decree could be passed without him. It noted that defendant No. 1 received the sale consideration from the purchasers and transferred it to proposed defendant No. 47's account.
¶ 16The court further observed that proposed defendant No. 47 had not alienated the suit plots, and that defendant No. 1 executed the registered sale deeds in favour of the purchasers.
¶ 16The petitioner's contention that the developer's presence was needed to prove the development agreement and the consideration transfer was not separately addressed in the reasoning.
¶ 10The court treated the developer's role as a matter of evidence rather than a ground for joinder.
¶ 1605Holding
The court answered the sole issue in the negative. Proposed defendant No. 47 is neither a necessary nor a proper party to the partition suit.
¶ 13–14, 16The writ petition is dismissed, and the trial court's order dated 21.09.2024 on I.A. No. 14 in O.S. No. 8/2022 is affirmed.
¶ 17Original Court PDF
SRI SHANKAR S/O. BHIMAPPA ALABALvsSMT ANNAPURNA W/O. APPASAB KODAGANUR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
