01Facts
The insolvent, Syed Hifzur Rahman Biyabani, filed I.P. No. 11 of 2019 seeking adjudication as insolvent. He was adjudicated by the Master on 29.04.2019.
¶ 2In his supporting affidavit, he stated that pledged jewels had been re-pledged in his name with South Indian Bank, Muthoot Mini Financiers and Manapuram Finance, and that loans raised on them were invested in real estate.
¶ 2The learned Single Judge passed at least 90 orders in the insolvency proceedings from 30.09.2019, described as mandamus-type orders. Pursuant to a 2020 direction, a Special Investigation Team was constituted, and the Reserve Bank of India was directed to file a sealed-cover report on NBFC violations.
¶ 3On 30.06.2023, the Single Judge passed the impugned order. It recorded consolidated abstracts of freezed, recovered, unrecovered, auctioned and redeemed gold, freezed cash, and pre-petition auctions. It also recorded that the insolvent's modus operandi involved re-pledging gold, and that the Pawnbrokers Act had been violated by finance companies.
¶ 4–6Paragraph 10 of that order contained findings against the banks' officers, which the appellants contested.
¶ 7Jewels were returned and are in the custody of the Official Assignee.
¶ 6Around 50 further orders followed, the last dated 27.09.2024. None of the orders, before or after 30.06.2023, was challenged except the impugned order.
¶ 7The appellant in OSA (CAD) No. 117 of 2023 contended that it had handed over 7,846.22 grams of gold and auctioned 19,123.24 grams, which are not relatable to the insolvent as per the pledgees' affidavits.
¶ 7The investigation was at its final stage.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether appeals under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent and Section 13(2) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (read with Section 8(2) of the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act, 1909) lie against the Single Judge's order of 30.06.2023 where that order, and the related insolvency orders, are in the nature of mandamus passed in insolvency jurisdiction and do not adjudicate the parties' rights.
¶ 8, 10ii.2. Whether, in the circumstances, the appellants' challenges to the findings against them (including the finding in para. 10 of the impugned order and the claim regarding 19,123.24 grams of auctioned gold) can be determined in appeal, or must first be canvassed before the Single Judge.
¶ 7, 1003Law Applied
The procedural basis for the appeals was Order 36 Rule 1 of the Original Side Rules, Clause 15 of the Letters Patent, Section 13(2) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, and Section 8(2) of the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act, 1909.
The Division Bench relied on the nature of the insolvency jurisdiction exercised by the Single Judge. It treated the impugned and related orders as mandamus passed in the exercise of that jurisdiction, based on the RBI and investigative reports, and not as adjudications of the parties' rights.
¶ 8, 10An appeal would not lie against mandamus-type insolvency orders that do not adjudicate the parties' rights, and the party challenging a finding bears the burden of establishing its case before the Single Judge.
¶ 10The Pawnbrokers Act is referred to only as the basis of the Single Judge's findings and is not separately applied by the Bench.
¶ 6Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 Section 13
Presidency-Towns Insolvency Act, 1909 Section 8
04Reasoning
The Bench reviewed the course of the insolvency proceedings and found that the orders were passed only in exercise of insolvency jurisdiction, were mandamus in character, and did not adjudicate the parties' rights.
¶ 8, 10The return of jewels was the sole direction issued to the financial institutions.
¶ 10Because the appellants had not challenged the other orders passed before or after 30.06.2023, the Bench treated the impugned order as one step in a continuing series of directions, and held that nothing survived in the appeals to determine the rights of the parties.
¶ 7, 10The Bench left the merits open. The appellant in OSA No. 181 of 2023 must show before the Single Judge that there was no violation by it. The appellant in OSA (CAD) No. 117 of 2023 must show that the 19,123.24 grams of auctioned gold is not relatable to the insolvent.
¶ 10The reasoning rests on the characterisation of the orders as non-adjudicatory and the absence of a live determination of rights. The Bench did not separately examine the maintainability of the Commercial Courts Act appeal against insolvency orders.
05Holding
The Division Bench held that the orders of the Single Judge are mandamus-type orders passed in insolvency jurisdiction, do not adjudicate rights, and therefore the appeals are not maintainable.
¶ 10All three appeals (OSA No. 181 of 2023, OSA (CAD) No. 117 of 2023 and OSA No. 216 of 2026) were dismissed, with no order as to costs. The appellants were granted liberty to canvass their points before the learned Single Judge, subject to the orders in the insolvency proceedings. The Bench did not disturb the findings in para. 10 of the 30.06.2023 order, which remain open to contest before the Single Judge.
¶ 7, 10Original Court PDF
FEDBANK FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITEDvsSYED HIFZUR RAHMAN BIYABANI
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
