Meghalaya High CourtConstitutional LawAdministrative and Public Law

Meghalaya HC Strikes Down Khasi Hills Council's Syiem Amendment Act, Saying Revised Changes Skipped House Vote

TOLENTINE WAHLANG AND ANR.v.THE STATE OF MEGHALAYA AND 6 ORS.

Meghalaya HC Strikes Down Khasi Hills Council's Syiem Amendment Act, Saying Revised Changes Skipped House Vote. TOLENTINE WAHLANG  AND ANR. vs THE STATE OF MEGHALAYA  AND 6 ORS.. Meghalaya High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the procedure prescribed under Rules 92(2) and 93 of the Assam and Meghalaya Autonomous Districts (Constitution of District Councils) Rules, 1951 was followed when the Governor's assent was obtained, and whether any deviation renders the statute ultra vires ab initio.

The court held

The Court answered the first issue in the negative: Rule 93 was not complied with, and the procedural departure is open to judicial review. The Court held that the Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) (Amendment) Act, 2019 is ultra vires for a "fatal departure from the mandatory legislative procedure prescribed by Rule 93 of the Rules of 1951". The Court did not expressly answer the second and third issues in separate terms, though its reasoning implicitly affirms judicial reviewability and holds that Governor's assent cannot cure the defect.

It also directed

The writ petition was allowed and disposed of.

01Facts

The petitioners challenged the Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) (Amendment) Act, 2019 as ultra vires, alleging violation of the mandatory legislative process and custom.

pp. 2–3 · ¶ 1

The Principal Act of 2006 was enacted under Paragraph 3 of the Sixth Schedule and received the Governor's assent under Paragraph 3(3).

p. 3 · ¶ 2

The Amendment Bill, passed by the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council (KHADC) on 25.07.2019, proposed three changes concerning Raid Saw Symper: (i) a proviso limiting the Act to village administration and excluding land administration; (ii) a provision equating the Myntri with the Rangbah Shnong (Headman); and (iii) a three-year term and election procedure for the Myntri/Headman.

pp. 3–4 · ¶ 3

The Maharam Syiemship filed written objections before the Governor, and the District Council Affairs Department (Respondent No. 2) communicated them to the KHADC on 17.10.2019.

pp. 4–5 · ¶ 4

On 15.02.2021, Respondent No. 2 informed the KHADC that the Bill had not received assent and asked for reconsideration; the KHADC clarified "land regulation" as "land administration".

p. 5 · ¶ 4

On 25.08.2023, the Law Department advised omitting Clause 2 (land administration) and Clause 3 (equating Myntri with Rangbah Shnong).

pp. 5–6 · ¶ 4 · p. 12 · ¶ 13

The Governor assented on 15.09.2023, and the Act was published on 26.09.2023 with Clause 2 omitted but Clauses 3 and 4 retained.

p. 12 · ¶ 13

The petitioners contended that the modified Bill was never re-tabled before the House.

pp. 6–7 · ¶ 5

The respondents argued that the Bill was passed by voice vote on 25.07.2019, that the changes were clerical, and that the return originated from the Law Department rather than the Governor.

pp. 8–10 · ¶ 7–8

An additional affidavit showed that on 01.09.2023 the Executive Committee agreed to the Law Department's observations and incorporated them under Rule 92(1) before resubmission.

p. 16 · ¶ 17

02Issues

i.1. Whether the procedure prescribed under Rules 92(2) and 93 of the Assam and Meghalaya Autonomous Districts (Constitution of District Councils) Rules, 1951 was followed when the Governor's assent was obtained, and whether any deviation renders the statute ultra vires ab initio.

p. 11 · ¶ 12

ii.2. Whether the Court has jurisdiction to examine the law-making process of the legislature.

p. 11 · ¶ 12

iii.3. Whether the Governor's assent to a Bill not placed before the House renders the Bill invalid.

p. 11 · ¶ 12

03Law Applied

The Court relied on Rule 92(2) and Rule 93 of the 1951 Rules, under which a Bill returned by the Governor with a message for reconsideration must have its recommended amendments put before the Council by the Chairman, discussed and voted upon "in the same manner as amendments to a Bill," and then re-presented for assent.

pp. 12–13 · ¶ 14–15

The Court applied Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachilhu (1992 Supp (2) SCC 651), holding that the validity of a law depends on the competence of the law-making authority and limitations on the mode of exercise of power.

pp. 14–15 · ¶ 16

The Court relied on Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India ((2016) 5 SCC 1), holding that a law enacted without following the prescribed procedure has no effect to that extent and that substantively illegal proceedings are not shielded by Article 122(1).

p. 15 · ¶ 16

The Court relied on Kaiser-I-Hind Pvt. Ltd. v. National Textile Corporation ((2002) 8 SCC 182), holding that assent under Article 254(2) forms part of the legislative procedure and that compliance with constitutional procedure is open to judicial scrutiny.

p. 15 · ¶ 16

Provisions in the judgment · 6

Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) Act, 2006 Section 1Section 2Section 8

Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) (Amendment) Act, 2019 Section 2Section 3Section 4

04Reasoning

The Court first held that the Governor's communication of 25.08.2023 was a formal return within Rule 93, not an internal administrative exchange, since the Bill was returned for reconsideration after the 15.02.2021 communication that assent had not been given. Because the return was formal, Rule 93 required the amendments to be placed before the House for discussion and vote, and the 2019 vote could not cover the later modifications.

p. 14 · ¶ 15

The Court rejected the respondents' argument that the changes were clerical. The 01.09.2023 letter showed that the Executive Committee had adopted substantive Law Department recommendations and incorporated them without placing them before the Chairman or the House, which the Court treated as executive encroachment on the legislative domain. The Court rejected the reliance on Articles 122 and 212, and on the presumption of validity and general arguments on arbitrariness and Article 14, holding that these could not override the specific requirement of Rule 93. The Court did not decide the Maharam custom question on its merits; its finding rests on the procedural defect.

pp. 15–17 · ¶ 16–18

05Holding

The Court answered the first issue in the negative: Rule 93 was not complied with, and the procedural departure is open to judicial review. The Court held that the Khasi Hills Autonomous District (Nomination and Election of the Syiem, Deputy Syiem and Electors of Hima Maharam) (Amendment) Act, 2019 is ultra vires for a "fatal departure from the mandatory legislative procedure prescribed by Rule 93 of the Rules of 1951". The Court did not expressly answer the second and third issues in separate terms, though its reasoning implicitly affirms judicial reviewability and holds that Governor's assent cannot cure the defect.

pp. 15–17 · ¶ 16–18

The writ petition was allowed and disposed of.

p. 17 · ¶ 19
Meghalaya High Court

Original Court PDF

TOLENTINE WAHLANG AND ANR.vsTHE STATE OF MEGHALAYA AND 6 ORS.

Meghalaya High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment