01Facts
The appellant, Mohd Yamin Ali, filed an intra-court special appeal against the single judge's judgment dated 22.02.2021 in WPMS No. 344 of 2021. The single judge had dismissed the appellant's challenge, under Article 227 of the Constitution, to the order dated 05.02.2021 of the 3rd Additional District Judge, Dehradun, in Land Acquisition Miscellaneous Case No. 786 of 2019.
¶ 3By that order, the District Judge allowed withdrawal of ₹54,50,775 in favour of the Secretary of the respondent society, Audyogik Avam Shaikshik Sansthan (respondent no. 3), subject to her giving an undertaking and affidavit to refund the amount if the High Court passed a contrary order.
¶ 4The background was Writ Petition No. 605 of 2011 (M/S), in which the appellant claimed to be the society's President. The Coordinate Bench on 20.05.2019 held that the dispute between the appellant and the Secretary, Leela Negi, over entitlement to compensation was a disputed question of fact, directed a regular civil suit, and granted two months to file it, failing which the amount was to be released to the society.
¶ 3No suit was filed. The review petition was dismissed on 12.10.2020. Special Appeal No. 312 of 2020 against those judgments was pending without any interim order in the appellant's favour. The award was put into execution and the amount was directed to be released.
¶ 5The single judge held that the writ petition was a cumulative and successive attempt to reagitate entitlement, and that the impugned order was in line with the 20.05.2019 judgment. No counsel appeared for the appellant at the hearing; the State was represented by Standing Counsel.
¶ 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether an intra-court special appeal lies against a single judge's judgment that decided a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenging an order of a subordinate civil court in land acquisition proceedings.
¶ 5–6ii.2. Whether, in view of Chapter VIII Rule 5 of the Rules of the Court, 1952, the special appeal is maintainable.
¶ 5–603Law Applied
Chapter VIII Rule 5 of the Rules of the Court, 1952 (Uttarakhand High Court Rules) provides that an appeal lies from a single judge's judgment in respect of a decree or order of a subordinate court, but not where the order was made in the exercise of superintendence or of the jurisdiction under Article 226 or 227 in respect of a judgment, order or award, subject to the bracketed exceptions for certain tribunal or Government orders under State or Concurrent List legislation.
¶ 5The bar under Chapter VIII Rule 5 applies where the single judge has exercised Article 227 supervisory jurisdiction over a subordinate court's order.
¶ 5–6No case law was cited in the order.
The Court did not expressly analyse whether the bracketed exceptions, which refer to Concurrent List subjects, applied to the land acquisition order.
04Reasoning
The Court first identified the nature of the proceeding. The writ petition challenged an order of the 3rd Additional District Judge in a land acquisition case, so it was necessarily a petition under Article 227.
¶ 5–6The Court then applied Rule 5 to that characterisation and concluded that the special appeal was barred, since the single judge's decision rested on superintendence over a subordinate court's order. The Court accepted the State's submission on maintainability.
¶ 5–6Because the appeal was held non-maintainable at the threshold, the Court did not examine the merits of the compensation dispute, the 20.05.2019 directions, or the pending Special Appeal No. 312 of 2020. The absence of appearance for the appellant also meant no contrary submission was recorded.
¶ 7 · ¶ 105Holding
The Division Bench held that the special appeal against a single judge's Article 227 judgment on an order passed by a subordinate court in land acquisition proceedings is not maintainable under Chapter VIII Rule 5 of the Rules of the Court, 1952.
¶ 5–6The special appeal is dismissed as not maintainable, without any finding on the merits. The Court's order does not disturb the pending Special Appeal No. 312 of 2020 or the release of compensation under the 05.02.2021 order, subject to the undertaking and refund condition noted at para. 4.
¶ 7 · ¶ 4Original Court PDF
MOHD YAMIN ALIvsSTATE OF UTTARAKHAND THROUGH DISTRICT MAGISTRATE,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
