01Facts
On 17 April 2011, Suman and Shakuntla were found murdered in village Ranila. The prosecution alleged that Naresh and co-accused Subhash had attacked them.
¶ 2–3The private witnesses, including the informant and the two witnesses said to have seen the assault, did not support the prosecution at trial.
¶ 13–21The Trial Court nevertheless convicted both accused under Sections 302, 449, 297 and 201 IPC and imposed the death penalty. The High Court acquitted Subhash but upheld Naresh’s convictions, commuting his death sentence to life imprisonment. Naresh appealed to the Supreme Court.
¶ 13–2102Issues
i.1. Whether the FIR and statements recorded under Section 161 CrPC could prove Naresh’s involvement or motive when the witnesses disowned them at trial.
¶ 28(a)ii.2. Whether the disclosure statements and recoveries of the danda and gandasi were proved under Section 27 of the Evidence Act and constituted incriminating circumstances.
¶ 28(b)iii.3. Whether the medical and forensic evidence connected Naresh with the deaths.
¶ 28(c)iv.4. Whether admissible evidence supported the charges under Sections 449, 297 and 201 IPC.
¶ 28(d)v.5. Whether Naresh could be convicted on evidence of the same kind as that on which the High Court acquitted Subhash.
¶ 28(e)03Law Applied
Section 162(1) CrPC bars the use of statements made to police during investigation, except for the limited purpose of contradiction in accordance with Section 145 of the Evidence Act; even a proved contradiction does not make the prior statement substantive evidence.
¶ 30–36 · Tahsildar Singh v. State of U.P. · ¶ 31 · V.K. Mishra v. State of Uttarakhand · ¶ 32An FIR is not substantive evidence and may ordinarily be used to corroborate or contradict its maker; a hearsay accusation in an FIR cannot prove the accused’s guilt.
¶ 43–44Under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, only the part of custodial information that distinctly relates to a fact discovered is admissible, and the disclosure and recovery must be proved through evidence of the information given and the discovery.
¶ 48–50 · Pulukuri Kottaya v. King-Emperor · ¶ 48 · Ramanand v. State of U.P. · ¶ 49A recovery or bloodstain does not, without reliable proof connecting it to the offence, establish guilt.
¶ 51, 63–64Circumstantial evidence must satisfy the five principles in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra: the circumstances must be fully established, consistent only with guilt, conclusive, exclude every other hypothesis, and form a complete chain.
¶ 67Material circumstances relied upon against an accused must ordinarily be put to that accused under Section 313 CrPC.
¶ 66The principle of parity requires like cases to be decided alike where the evidence and roles are materially similar.
¶ 72–74 · Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi v. State of Gujarat · ¶ 72Provisions in the judgment · 14 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 449Section 297Section 201Section 34
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 357Section 173Section 313Section 162Section 366Section 161Section 164Section 154
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 396
04Reasoning
The Court held that no private witness implicated Naresh in testimony; the police statements were therefore unavailable as substantive proof under Section 162 CrPC, and the hearsay FIR could not fill that evidentiary gap.
¶ 35–47The disclosure statements were not proved because the investigating officers did not testify to the words used by Naresh. The recovered danda was not connected to the fatal incised wounds, while the later gandasi recovery followed a materially inconsistent second disclosure and was supported by conflicting evidence about its time and place.
¶ 50–61The medical opinion showed only that the gandasi could have caused the injuries, not that it did; the forensic results did not identify the blood as that of either deceased, and relevant circumstances were not put to Naresh under Section 313 CrPC.
¶ 62–66The remaining circumstances did not form a complete chain, and the evidence against Naresh was materially the same as that held insufficient against Subhash.
¶ 68–7405Holding
The Court answered all five issues against the prosecution and held that Naresh’s guilt had not been proved beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 75–78It allowed the appeals, set aside the convictions and sentences, and acquitted Naresh of all charges; it directed his release if not required in another case and set aside the compensation order and any deposited fine.
¶ 78–80The Court recommended that the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, consider victim compensation for the deceased women’s legal representatives.
¶ 81Original Court PDF
NareshvsState Of Haryana
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
