01Facts
The plaintiffs sought declaration and permanent injunction concerning properties in Survey Nos. 368/13 and 368/4.
¶ 2, 10In the suit, they obtained appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to inspect and measure the properties with the assistance of a Village Administrative Officer and surveyor, referring to the parties’ title deeds and relevant revenue records.
¶ 2, 10The Commissioner inspected the properties and submitted a preliminary report and plan, but later reported that the surveyor could not measure the properties with reference to the plaintiffs’ sale deeds and asked the trial Court to treat the preliminary report as final.
¶ 3, 11The plaintiffs’ application to set aside the report and reissue the commission was dismissed; they challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 5, 802Issues
i.Whether the trial Court was justified in dismissing the plaintiffs’ application to set aside the preliminary report and plan and reissue the commission for a fresh inspection and measurement
¶ 8ii.Whether the Commissioner’s investigation was complete where he relied on the surveyor’s inability to measure by reference to the sale deeds without further attempting to correlate the deeds with available records and physical features
¶ 11–1403Law Applied
Order XXVI Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 empowers a court to direct a local investigation where it is requisite or proper to elucidate a matter in dispute; in a property-demarcation dispute, such an investigation may assist the court in ascertaining physical features and boundaries.
¶ 9, 15–16The Supreme Court’s decision in Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, (2008) 8 SCC 671, supports appointing a Local Commissioner where demarcation of disputed land is in issue.
¶ 9, 15–16A Commissioner must make reasonable efforts to complete the investigation entrusted to him, but may not adjudicate title or the parties’ substantive rights.
¶ 12, 1704Reasoning
The dispute concerned the identity, boundaries and measurements of the suit properties, making local investigation relevant.
¶ 11–14, 17The Commissioner’s report was not comprehensive because he relied on the surveyor’s stated inability without adequately examining the title deeds and available revenue and survey records or attempting to correlate them with the properties on the ground.
¶ 11–14, 17The trial Court’s suggestion that the plaintiffs could instead examine the officials as witnesses did not substitute for the local investigation required to elucidate the dispute.
¶ 18The Commissioner was therefore required to complete the investigation, while leaving questions of title and evidentiary weight to the trial Court.
¶ 17, 1905Holding
The High Court allowed the revision petition, set aside the impugned order and directed the trial Court to reissue the commission warrant to the same Advocate Commissioner.
¶ 20–21The Commissioner was directed, after notice to both parties, to examine the relevant title deeds and revenue and survey records; inspect and measure the properties with the assistance of the Village Administrative Officer and a qualified surveyor; report boundaries, physical features and discrepancies; and explain any inability to identify or measure a property.
¶ 21(a)–(f)The Court clarified that its observations did not determine title, possession or other substantive rights, and left those matters for independent adjudication by the trial Court.
¶ 21(g)No costs were ordered.
¶ 22Original Court PDF
DHARMALINGAMvsDEVEBURMAN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
