Telangana High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceConstitutional Law

Telangana HC Refuses Crash Claimants' Bid to Shift Blame to Other Car After Trial Evidence Began

Mittapally Lakshmi Shyamalav.The Oriental Insurance Company LTD,

Telangana HC Refuses Crash Claimants' Bid to Shift Blame to Other Car After Trial Evidence Began. Mittapally Lakshmi Shyamala vs The Oriental Insurance Company LTD,. Telangana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the trial Court erred in refusing leave under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend the claim petitions, where the amendment would shift the allegation of rash and negligent driving from the Maruti driver to respondent No. 4 and introduce a new sequence of events, after the trial had reached cross-examination.

The court held

The proposed amendments would introduce a new and different case and change the nature and character of the claim petitions. The trial Court's refusal of leave under Order VI Rule 17 CPC was therefore proper.

It also directed

No ground for interference under Article 227 was found. The trial Court's reasoning was found to be cogent and based on proper appreciation of the pleadings, with no jurisdictional error or perversity.

All four Civil Revision Petitions (C.R.P. Nos. 2457, 2465, 2467 and 2479 of 2026) are dismissed, and the orders dated 03.03.2026 in I.A. Nos. 790, 791, 792 and 793 of 2024 are confirmed. No costs are awarded. Pending miscellaneous applications stand closed.

01Facts

The claimants, who were travelling in a Maruti Wagon R car (MH-27-AR-3129) with their parents, were injured in an accident at Bargi, Uttara Kannada, Karnataka, on 22.05.2018. Their parents died in the accident.

¶ 2.2

The claimants' original M.V.O.Ps. (M.V.O.P. Nos. 25/2021, 105/2020, 48/2020 and 47/2020) pleaded that the accident was caused solely by the rash and negligent driving of the Maruti driver.

¶ 6

The Mahindra Xylo car (KA-19-MB-1019), owned and driven by respondent No. 4 and insured by respondent No. 5, was already impleaded.

¶ 4.2, 6

F.I.R. No. 49 of 2018 was registered on respondent No. 4's complaint. The investigating officer's final report charged only the Maruti driver and was marked as Ex.A.4.

¶ 7

When RW-2 was due for cross-examination, the claimants filed I.A. Nos. 790–793 of 2024 under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend the pleadings. The amendment sought to plead that the Xylo car was on the wrong side of the road, that the Maruti driver turned right to avoid it, hit the divider, and then collided with the Xylo.

¶ 2.3, 7

The trial Court dismissed all four applications by orders dated 03.03.2026.

¶ 2.4, 7

The claimants filed these revision petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution.

¶ 1.1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the trial Court erred in refusing leave under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend the claim petitions, where the amendment would shift the allegation of rash and negligent driving from the Maruti driver to respondent No. 4 and introduce a new sequence of events, after the trial had reached cross-examination.

¶ 8, 11, 13

ii.2. Whether the impugned orders warranted interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.

¶ 14

03Law Applied

Order VI Rule 17 CPC governs amendment of pleadings and was argued by the parties.

¶ 5.3

The grant of amendment under Order VI Rule 17 CPC is discretionary and aimed at determining the real questions in controversy.

¶ 10

Varun Pahwa v. Renu Chaudhary (2019) 15 SCC 628 holds that amendment cannot be refused merely for inadvertence, negligence or procedural infraction, and that leave is given to serve the ends of justice.

¶ 9

Haramani Sahoo v. Lalita Nayak (2026 LawSuit (SC) 1217) reaffirms the discretionary nature of Order VI Rule 17.

¶ 10

Revajeetu Builders & Developers v. Narayanaswamy & Sons (2009) 10 SCC 84 sets out guiding principles: the court must examine whether the amendment is imperative for proper adjudication, whether the application is bona fide or mala fide, whether it prejudices the opposite party, and, most importantly, whether it fundamentally alters the nature and character of the case.

¶ 12

Article 227 of the Constitution confers supervisory jurisdiction over subordinate tribunals.

¶ 14

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279Section 337Section 338

04Reasoning

The original pleadings consistently attributed the accident solely to the Maruti driver's negligence, and the police final report (Ex.A.4) was consistent with that case.

¶ 6, 7

The proposed amendment did not correct an inadvertent error, clerical mistake or procedural irregularity. It replaced the claimants' case with a different version of the accident, shifting liability to respondent No. 4 and adding a new sequence of events.

¶ 8, 11, 13

The liberal approach in Varun Pahwa and Haramani Sahoo addresses bona fide corrections, not a change in the nature and character of the case, and those decisions were therefore held inapplicable.

¶ 11

Applying Revajeetu, the amendment would fundamentally change the character of the claim petitions, which was decisive against allowing it, even though respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were already parties and the claimants' counsel argued no prejudice.

¶ 4.2, 12, 13

05Holding

The proposed amendments would introduce a new and different case and change the nature and character of the claim petitions. The trial Court's refusal of leave under Order VI Rule 17 CPC was therefore proper.

¶ 8, 13

No ground for interference under Article 227 was found. The trial Court's reasoning was found to be cogent and based on proper appreciation of the pleadings, with no jurisdictional error or perversity.

¶ 8, 14

All four Civil Revision Petitions (C.R.P. Nos. 2457, 2465, 2467 and 2479 of 2026) are dismissed, and the orders dated 03.03.2026 in I.A. Nos. 790, 791, 792 and 793 of 2024 are confirmed. No costs are awarded. Pending miscellaneous applications stand closed.

¶ 15
Telangana High Court

Original Court PDF

Mittapally Lakshmi ShyamalavsThe Oriental Insurance Company LTD,

Telangana High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment