01Facts
The claimant was injured on 06.05.1998 when a bus (HR-39/2828) was driven rashly and negligently by respondent-driver.
¶ 1The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sirsa, awarded Rs. 80,000 by award dated 04.02.2002, comprising medical expenses (Rs. 24,000), pain and suffering (Rs. 5,000), loss of income (Rs. 6,000), special diet and attendant charges (Rs. 5,000), and permanent disability (Rs. 40,000).
¶ 3No appeal or cross-objection was filed by respondents on rashness or negligence, so only quantum was in issue.
¶ 2The claimant, aged 45, pleaded ownership of 15 acres and income of Rs. 15,000 per month, and claimed 32% permanent disability and Rs. 1,50,000 in treatment expenses.
¶ 4, 5He had multiple fractures, including of the right femur and both bones of the right leg, was operated on 18.05.1998, and remained hospitalised from 06.05.1998 to 28.05.1998.
¶ 6, 7Medical bills proved expenditure above Rs. 12,000.
¶ 7The treating surgeon (PW-3) and a disability witness (PW-1, relying on Ex. P-99) testified; the 32% disability related to limited movement of the right ankle and knee and foot drop.
¶ 6, 8No revenue records or J-forms were produced to prove land ownership.
¶ 9The claimant's status as an agriculturist/labourer was unrebutted.
¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the claimant is entitled to compensation computed on the basis of functional disability, where permanent disability is 32%.
¶ 4, 8ii.2. Whether the Tribunal erred in not assessing the claimant's income at the pleaded Rs. 15,000 per month, given the failure to prove land ownership.
¶ 4, 9iii.3. Whether future prospects at 25% are to be added to income in computing loss of earning capacity.
¶ 4, 10iv.4. Whether the multiplier applied by the Tribunal was appropriate.
¶ 4, 10v.5. Whether compensation for loss of future prospects/amenities of life and future medical expenses is payable.
¶ 4, 12vi.6. Whether the awards for pain and suffering, medical expenses, special diet, transportation, attendant charges, and loss of income during treatment are inadequate and require enhancement.
¶ 4, 7, 8, 1203Law Applied
The principle that loss of earning capacity is computed by multiplying annual income, after adding future prospects, by the applicable multiplier and the functional disability percentage.
¶ 10, 11, 13National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680, relied on for the addition of 25% future prospects to income where the injured is below 50 years of age.
¶ 10Smt. Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation (2009) 6 SCC 121, relied on for the multiplier of 14 applicable to the injured's age bracket.
¶ 10Income for an agriculturist/labourer without proof of earnings is determined by the minimum wage for an unskilled worker in the year of accident.
¶ 9The general principle that compensation must be just and reasonable, requiring proof for future medical expenses and for claims of special damages.
¶ 9, 1204Reasoning
The claimant's ownership of 15 acres was unproven, as no revenue records or oral evidence corroborated it, so income was fixed at Rs. 2,000 per month based on the 1998 unskilled minimum wage.
¶ 9Because the claimant's manual labour work was unrebutted and the disability affected the ankle, knee and foot, the Court held that the claimant would find manual work difficult and adopted a 32% functional disability.
¶ 8Future prospects at 25% (Rs. 500) were added to the Rs. 2,000 income, yielding Rs. 2,500, and 32% of that amount (Rs. 800) was taken as the monthly loss; applying the multiplier of 14 gave Rs. 1,34,400.
¶ 10, 11, 13Since the disability was 32%, the Court held that the claimant was deprived of future prospects and amenities and awarded Rs. 75,000 under that head.
¶ 12Given the multiple fractures, the claimant was presumed to be out of work for six months, yielding Rs. 12,000 for loss of income.
¶ 12Future medical expenses were disallowed as they were neither pleaded nor proved.
¶ 12The Court enhanced pain and suffering to Rs. 75,000 in view of multiple fractures and surgery, and consolidated medical expenses, special diet, transportation and attendant charges at Rs. 20,000 based on the nature of injuries and the hospitalisation period.
¶ 805Holding
The claimant is entitled to compensation based on a 32% functional disability, a monthly income of Rs. 2,000, 25% future prospects, and a multiplier of 14.
¶ 10, 11The appeal is allowed. Total compensation is re-computed at Rs. 3,16,400 (loss of earning capacity Rs. 1,34,400; loss of income Rs. 12,000; medical, diet and attendant charges Rs. 20,000; pain and suffering Rs. 75,000; future prospects and amenities Rs. 75,000). After deducting the Tribunal's award of Rs. 80,000, the enhancement is Rs. 2,36,400.
¶ 13, 14The claimant is entitled to interest at 7.5% per annum on the enhanced amount from the date of filing the claim petition until realisation, and the respondents' liability is to be as per the award. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
¶ 14, 16Original Court PDF
Mahender SinghvsSulakhan Singh Etc.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
