01Facts
The appellant, a trustee of Priyadarshini Charitable Trust, held land (City Survey No. 1888) gifted to the Trust in 1992 and mutated in its name.
¶ 6A civil suit (S.C.S. No. 53 of 2003) concerning separate land (Survey Nos. 42/2 and 44/7) was decreed on 01.08.2018, declaring a 1992 sale deed not binding on the plaintiffs, one of whom was Accused No. 1.
¶ 6–7On the same day, Accused No. 1 applied to the City Survey Officer (Respondent No. 1, Accused No. 2) for mutation, which the appellant alleges was unsigned and unsupported by documents.
¶ 8The decree was stayed on 22.11.2018.
¶ 9Mutation Entry No. 7062 was approved on 16.11.2018 and later cancelled by the Superintendent of Land Records on 30.11.2019.
¶ 14, 21The Magistrate directed investigation under s. 156(3) CrPC on 17.03.2020 and 04.03.2021.
¶ 15, 19FIR No. 79/2020 and FIR No. 62/2021 were registered.
¶ 16, 19Respondent No. 1 was suspended on 05.08.2020.
¶ 17Chargesheets alleged that Respondent No. 1 and others forged and tampered with the mutation application (including pasted photographs, altered entries and a reference to a document destroyed in a 2011 fire) and conspired to cheat under ss. 465, 466, 468, 471, 474, 420, 120B r/w 34 IPC.
¶ 21–22The High Court quashed the proceedings in RCC Nos. 1020/2023 and 119/2024 on the ground that s. 197 CrPC sanction (under the Maharashtra amendment to s. 156(3)) was absent and the sanction applications were made to non-competent authorities.
¶ 3–4, 2302Issues
i.1. Whether the acts attributed to Respondent No. 1 (forging and tampering with the mutation application and facilitating a fraudulent mutation entry) were committed in the discharge or purported discharge of his official duty, so as to attract s. 197 CrPC read with the Maharashtra amendment to s. 156(3) CrPC.
¶ 25–27, 32, 35ii.2. Whether the questions of deemed sanction under the proviso and the competent sanctioning authority need to be decided.
¶ 3203Law Applied
The Maharashtra proviso to s. 156(3) CrPC bars a Magistrate from ordering investigation against a public servant for acts done in discharge of official duty without previous sanction under s. 197 CrPC, and deems sanction if the sanctioning authority does not decide within 90 days.
¶ 30Section 197(1) CrPC requires sanction for offences alleged to have been committed while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of official duty.
¶ 31Om Prakash Yadav v. Niranjan Kumar Upadhyay, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3726 holds that the act complained of must be integrally or reasonably connected with official duty, that the "safe and sure test" is whether omission to commit the act would make the officer answerable for dereliction of duty, and that protection does not extend to acts dehors duty.
¶ 33, citing paras. 65(iv), (vi), (x), (xi)Om Prakash Yadav v. Niranjan Kumar Upadhyay, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3726 holds that criminal conspiracy to create false or fabricated documents cannot fall within the protection of s. 197 CrPC.
¶ 33, citing para. 66Provisions in the judgment · 11 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 465Section 466Section 468Section 471Section 474Section 420Section 34
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 156Section 190Section 197Section 482
04Reasoning
The Court examined the nature of the act rather than the public servant's general office.
¶ 33The prosecution case was that Respondent No. 1 conspired to prepare forged documents, presented them as genuine, and used them to effect a mutation with intent to cheat and transfer property to Accused No. 1 and others.
¶ 21, 22, 34The Court held that no part of an official's duty includes forging documents or manipulating records to benefit private parties, and that the omission to commit such acts would not render the officer liable for dereliction of duty.
¶ 33, 34The fact that the officer had an opportunity to act because of his position was insufficient to invoke protection.
¶ 33, citing para. 67The State's and respondent's submissions that the mutation followed a process and legal opinion did not alter the character of the alleged act, which was forgery and fabrication.
¶ 27, 28Because the acts fell outside official duty, the Court found it unnecessary to decide the deemed-sanction and competent-authority issues.
¶ 32The Court expressly limited its observations to the sanction question and directed that the trial proceed independently on its merits.
¶ 3505Holding
The Supreme Court held that the acts attributed to Respondent No. 1 were not committed in the discharge or purported discharge of official duty, so neither s. 197 CrPC nor the Maharashtra proviso to s. 156(3) applied.
¶ 32, 35The Court did not decide the deemed-sanction or competent-authority questions.
¶ 32The Court set aside the High Court's order dated 27.11.2024 in Criminal Application Nos. 1371 of 2020 and 3235 of 2021, allowed the appeals, and directed that RCC Nos. 1020 of 2023 and 119 of 2024 be restored to the file of the CJM, Dhule, to be proceeded with in accordance with law.
¶ 36Original Court PDF
AshokvsMahesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
