01Facts
The plaintiff/opposite party (Annapurna Nandi) filed Title Suit No. 223 of 2022 in the Court of the Civil Judge (Junior Division), 1st Court, Serampore, Hooghly, seeking eviction of the defendant/petitioner (Debasis Pal) under Section 6(1) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997 on grounds including default in rent and reasonable requirement.
¶ 10The plaint alleged that the defendant's father was inducted as a monthly tenant of a shop room by the plaintiff's husband, that the father died around 2018, and that the defendant had since occupied the suit property without authority.
¶ 7The written statement admitted the father's death around 2018 but denied that the property was lying vacant under lock and key.
¶ 8–9The suit was filed in 2022, before the five-year period under Section 2(g) had expired.
¶ 10During pendency, the five-year period expired, and the plaintiff applied under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend the plaint to plead cessation of the landlord-tenant relationship by operation of law.
¶ 2, 4, 22By order No. 78 dated 24.09.2026, the trial court allowed the amendment.
¶ 2The defendant challenged that order under Article 226 of the Constitution, arguing that the amendment would convert an eviction suit under the special statute into a trespass suit under general law and relying on Samir Kumar Kundu v. Dipali Roy (C.O. 3022 of 2019, decided 13.11.2019).
¶ 3The revisional application was numbered C.O. 3786 of 2026.
¶ 3102Issues
i.1. Whether an amendment of the plaint pleading that the defendant's tenancy ceased by operation of law under Section 2(g) of the 1997 Act after expiry of five years from the tenant's death changes the nature and character of the eviction suit, and is therefore impermissible.
¶ 3 · ¶ 26ii.2. Whether the trial court's order allowing the amendment warrants interference in exercise of the High Court's jurisdiction.
¶ 3003Law Applied
Section 6(1) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, which bars recovery of possession except by suit on specified grounds.
¶ 11–13Section 7 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, which requires the landlord to pay or deposit rent to obtain protection, with both provisions presupposing a landlord-tenant relationship.
¶ 11–13Section 2(g) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, which defines "tenant" to include a deceased tenant's son for up to five years from the tenant's death (or from the Act's commencement, whichever is later) in respect of non-residential premises, and which excludes persons against whom an eviction order has been passed.
¶ 14–17, 19The settled principle that subsequent events may be introduced by amendment of pleadings.
¶ 26Pleadings are not proof, so the amended facts must still be established by evidence.
¶ 27Samir Kumar Kundu v. Dipali Roy (C.O. 3022 of 2019, decided 13.11.2019), distinguished on the ground that there the tenancy was admitted and the amendment would have withdrawn that admission.
¶ 28–2904Reasoning
Section 2(g) terminates the landlord-tenant relationship between the landlord and a deceased tenant's son, in respect of non-residential premises, once five years have passed from the tenant's death where the death occurred after the 1997 Act came into force.
¶ 19The father's death around 2018 was admitted, and the suit was filed in 2022, before the five-year period expired.
¶ 9, 20, 21The amendment sought only to plead that this change had occurred during the suit's pendency. Because the change operated in the plaintiff's favour, it did not strip the tenant of protection; it reflected a loss of protection by operation of law, which could be pleaded.
¶ 22–25Since the suit would remain one for eviction after amendment, the amendment did not change its nature or character.
¶ 26Samir Kumar Kundu is distinguishable because there the predecessor's death predated the 1997 Act and the tenancy had been admitted through a rent receipt; here no admitted tenancy was being displaced, and the plaintiff only sought the benefit of the statutory redefinition of "tenant".
¶ 28–29The plaintiff must still prove the amended facts by evidence.
¶ 2705Holding
On Issue 1, the Court answered in the negative: the amendment incorporating cessation of tenancy under Section 2(g) by operation of law is a permissible subsequent event and does not change the nature or character of the eviction suit.
¶ 26On Issue 2, the Court held that the trial court's order was not liable to interference.
¶ 30The writ/revisional application C.O. 3786 of 2026 is dismissed without costs.
¶ 31The trial court's order allowing the amendment of the plaint under Order VI Rule 17 CPC stands, and urgent certified copies may be supplied on compliance with formalities.
¶ 32Original Court PDF
DEBASIS PALvsANNAPURNA NANDI
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
