Calcutta High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceBanking and Finance Law

Calcutta HC Refuses Cross-Examination of Bank Officer in SARFAESI Auction Challenge, Citing Summary Scheme

M/S JATADHARI RICE MILL AND ANRv.PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK, ARMB MURSHIDABAD AND ANR

Calcutta HC Refuses Cross-Examination of Bank Officer in SARFAESI Auction Challenge, Citing Summary Scheme. M/S JATADHARI RICE MILL AND ANR vs PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK, ARMB MURSHIDABAD AND ANR. Calcutta High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the High Court should entertain a revisional application under Article 227 against an interlocutory order of the DRT, filed beyond the period for a Section 18 appeal and despite the statutory alternative remedy.

The court held

The revisional application did not merit entertainment because it was filed beyond the reasonable time for a statutory appeal without explanation.

It also directed

No jurisdictional error, natural justice violation, or perversity was shown, and no extraordinary circumstances justified cross-examination of the bank's authorised officer.

The impugned order rejecting IA 824 of 2025 was not interfered with. CO 136 of 2026 was disposed of with no order as to costs. The Tribunal was requested to dispose of SA 171 of 2024 expeditiously, preferably within six months from the next date fixed, without unnecessary adjournments. Certified copies were to be supplied on application.

01Facts

The petitioner, a partnership firm, availed credit facilities from Oriental Bank of Commerce, which later merged with Punjab National Bank (the bank). Its properties and its partners' properties were mortgaged as security.

¶ 3–4

After alleged default, the bank initiated proceedings under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002 and proceeded to sell the secured assets by auction.

¶ 5

The petitioners filed SA 171 of 2024 before the DRT Siliguri under Section 17.

¶ 6

In that case the petitioners filed IA 823 of 2025, seeking production of original loan and SARFAESI documents, postal receipts, track reports and notices, and IA 824 of 2025, seeking a direction that the bank's authorised officer appear and "adduce evidence".

¶ 7–9

By order dated 29.06.2026, the Tribunal allowed IA 823 and rejected IA 824.

¶ 2, 10

The petitioners challenged the rejection of IA 824 by revisional application under Article 227 filed on 17.08.2026.

¶ 11, 21

The petitioners contended that (i) cross-examination was needed to test the bank's affidavit, (ii) the bank failed to prove pre-sale affixation of the sale notice, (iii) a notice was issued to a dead person, and (iv) postal receipts relating to an earlier failed sale were used for the impugned sale.

¶ 12–16

The bank argued that a statutory appeal under Section 18 was available and that no extraordinary case for cross-examination existed.

¶ 18

02Issues

i.1. Whether the High Court should entertain a revisional application under Article 227 against an interlocutory order of the DRT, filed beyond the period for a Section 18 appeal and despite the statutory alternative remedy.

¶ 20–24

ii.2. Whether, in proceedings under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act, cross-examination of the bank's authorised officer is necessary to adjudicate the petitioners' challenge to the sale.

¶ 26–29

iii.3. Whether the Tribunal's rejection of IA 824 of 2025 is without jurisdiction, contrary to natural justice, or perverse.

¶ 25

03Law Applied

Section 18 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002 provides an appeal to the Appellate Tribunal within 30 days of receipt of a Section 17 order.

¶ 21

Article 227 petitions have no fixed limitation but must be filed within reasonable time; where a statutory appeal exists, the period for that appeal is the outer limit of reasonableness.

¶ 22

A litigant who forgoes a statutory remedy through his own fault cannot invoke discretionary constitutional relief, as held in A.V. Venkateswaran v. Ramchand Sobhraj Wadhwani, AIR 1961 SC 1506.

¶ 23–24

Tribunals may decide on documents and affidavits, and oral examination of a witness should arise only where there is a very good reason, as held in Union of India v. Delhi High Court Bar Assn., (2002) 4 SCC 275.

¶ 30

DRT proceedings are summary in nature and ordinarily exclude detailed examination and cross-examination, which is an exception, as held in Nahar Industrial Enterprises Ltd. v. Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corpn., (2009) 8 SCC 646.

¶ 31

Roma Roy v. Indian Overseas Bank, CO 74 of 2024 (Cal. HC, 16.05.2024) was held distinguishable on its facts.

¶ 29

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 Section 13Section 17Section 18

Recovery Of Debts And Bankruptcy Act, 1993 Section 19

04Reasoning

The revision was filed about seven weeks after the 30-day statutory appeal window had closed, with no explanation offered. Applying Venkateswaran, the petitioners could not invoke Article 227 to bypass the statutory appeal they had allowed to lapse.

¶ 21–24

The impugned order was not shown to be without jurisdiction, violative of natural justice, or perverse, which removed any basis for interference on merits.

¶ 25

None of the petitioners' grounds, including the alleged notice to a deceased person and the use of postal records from a failed sale, required oral testimony. These were factual matters verifiable from the documents the bank had placed on affidavit, and the Tribunal had already ordered production of the originals for inspection.

¶ 27

Whether the statutory procedure was followed, including the bank's averments in its affidavit, could be determined by the Tribunal on the documentary record without cross-examination.

¶ 28

Roma Roy was distinguished because there the Tribunal had to determine the debt on evidence tendered by affidavit, whereas here the application was being decided on the petition and written objections.

¶ 29

The 2002 Act's summary scheme does not ordinarily contemplate cross-examination, so the cited authorities supported the Tribunal's refusal.

¶ 30–32

05Holding

The revisional application did not merit entertainment because it was filed beyond the reasonable time for a statutory appeal without explanation.

¶ 21–24

No jurisdictional error, natural justice violation, or perversity was shown, and no extraordinary circumstances justified cross-examination of the bank's authorised officer.

¶ 25–28, 32

The impugned order rejecting IA 824 of 2025 was not interfered with. CO 136 of 2026 was disposed of with no order as to costs. The Tribunal was requested to dispose of SA 171 of 2024 expeditiously, preferably within six months from the next date fixed, without unnecessary adjournments. Certified copies were to be supplied on application.

¶ 33–36
Calcutta High Court

Original Court PDF

M/S JATADHARI RICE MILL AND ANRvsPUNJAB NATIONAL BANK, ARMB MURSHIDABAD AND ANR

Calcutta High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment