Allahabad High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Belated material improvements absent from the FIR and earlier statements render grave sexual assault charges unsustainable.

Shailendra Chauhanv.State Of U.P. And 3 Others

Belated material improvements absent from the FIR and earlier statements render grave sexual assault charges unsustainable.. Shailendra Chauhan vs State Of U.P. And 3 Others. Allahabad High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt the offences under Sections 376 and 201 IPC, Section 67-B IT Act, and Sections 5(e)/6 and 13/14 POCSO Act.

The court held

The Court held that the prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt the offences under Sections 376 and 201 IPC, Section 67-B IT Act, and Sections 5(e)/6 and 13/14 POCSO Act, and that the trial court's findings on these were perverse and unsustainable.

It also directed

The appeal was partly allowed and the appellant was acquitted of the charges under Sections 376 and 201 IPC, Section 67-B IT Act, and Sections 5(e)/6 and 13/14 POCSO Act.

The conviction under Section 354-A IPC and Section 9/10 POCSO Act was confirmed, along with the trial court's sentence under those provisions.

All sentences were ordered to run concurrently, with the period of incarceration already undergone adjusted against the substantive sentence.

The trial court records were directed to be sent to the District and Sessions Judge, Bhadohi, for compliance.

01Facts

The appellant, Shailendra Chauhan, who is not a qualified doctor but runs an optical shop within Parvati Hospital, Bhadohi, was convicted by the Additional Sessions Judge/Special Judge (POCSO), Bhadohi, in Sessions Trial No. 394 of 2021 under Sections 354-A, 376 and 201 IPC, Section 67-B of the IT Act, and Sections 9/10, 13/14 and 5(e)/6 of the POCSO Act

¶ 2 · ¶ 52

The 12-year-old victim's mother (P.W.-1) lodged a written complaint on 08.10.2021 alleging touching of private parts on 28.09.2021 and earlier occasions

¶ 14

The complaint was prepared at the police station on the Station Incharge's dictation, and the mother admitted she had no personal knowledge of the incident and relied on what others told her

¶ 17–18

The check FIR (08.10.2021) was registered under Section 354-A IPC and Sections 7/8 POCSO

¶ 14 · ¶ 36

The P.W.-4 constable dated the incident as 22.09.2021 in cross-examination, a discrepancy with the 28.09.2021 date in the FIR

¶ 36

The mother stated that a co-villager, Suraj Rai, showed her a video, which was never produced in original, sent for FSL examination, or linked to the appellant's face; Suraj Rai was never examined

¶ 6 · ¶ 15 · ¶ 38–39 · ¶ 46

The first I.O. (P.W.-5) filed a charge sheet under Section 354-A IPC and Sections 9/10, 13/14 POCSO

¶ 37

The Superintendent of Police later ordered further investigation without recorded reasons; the second I.O. (P.W.-6) added Sections 376 and 201 IPC, Section 5(e)/6 POCSO and Section 67-B IT Act, relying on the video, and charge-sheeted Dr. Manoj Chauhan separately

¶ 43 · ¶ 47

The proceedings against Dr. Manoj Chauhan were stayed by the High Court

¶ 4

The victim's statements under Sections 161 and 164 Cr.P.C. (and the first medical examination) disclosed only touching; the finger-insertion allegation first appeared in a further Section 161 statement recorded on 17.11.2021

¶ 5 · ¶ 9–10 · ¶ 23–25

At trial the victim additionally implicated Manoj Chauhan and Santosh Chauhan, which she had omitted earlier

¶ 26–27 · ¶ 31

The victim admitted that she never told anyone about the incident and that she was not examined by the doctor for finger insertion

¶ 28 · ¶ 31

The victim and her mother refused internal medical examination on the first two occasions; the third examination (15.11.2021) found no internal injury, and the victim did not mention finger insertion to the doctor

¶ 48–51

The appellant, in his Section 313 Cr.P.C. statement, denied the charges and alleged political motivation, enmity and extortion, and the defence witness D.W.-1 (a hospital employee) supported him

¶ 52–55

02Issues

i.1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt the offences under Sections 376 and 201 IPC, Section 67-B IT Act, and Sections 5(e)/6 and 13/14 POCSO Act.

¶ 62

ii.2. Whether the sole testimony of the prosecutrix, in light of her material improvements and the absence of corroboration, is credible enough to sustain conviction.

¶ 19 · ¶ 22 · ¶ 56

iii.3. Whether the delay in lodging the FIR and the unexplained absence of the video's original source and FSL report vitiate the prosecution case.

¶ 4 · ¶ 21 · ¶ 56 · ¶ 60

iv.4. Whether the conviction under Section 354-A IPC and Sections 9/10 POCSO Act is sustainable.

¶ 61 · ¶ 63–64

03Law Applied

The Court applied Section 354-A IPC (sexual harassment, including physical contact and advances), Section 376 IPC (rape), Section 201 IPC (causing disappearance of evidence), Section 67-B IT Act (publishing or transmitting child sexual material), Sections 5(e)/6 POCSO (penetrative/aggravated penetrative assault by hospital staff), Sections 9/10 POCSO (aggravated sexual assault by hospital staff), and Sections 13/14 POCSO (use of child for pornography).

¶ 3

Under Section 42 POCSO, where an act constitutes an offence under both POCSO and the IPC, the offender is liable under the law providing the greater punishment; this was used to confine the conviction to Section 354-A IPC and Section 9/10 POCSO.

¶ 61

Lal Mandi v. State of West Bengal, (1995) 3 SCC 603: the benefit of reasonable doubt must be given where two views are possible and graver punishment requires stricter proof.

¶ 15

Kuldip Yadav v. State of Bihar, 2011 (2) SCC (Cri) 632: the credibility of witnesses must be tested.

¶ 16

Paramjeet Singh @ Pamma v. State of Uttarakhand, AIR 2011 SC 200: the prosecution's burden under Sections 101 and 104 of the Evidence Act.

¶ 20

Paramjit Singh Bedi v. State of Punjab, 2026 INSC 1054: a prosecutrix's sole testimony sustains conviction only if it inspires confidence.

¶ 22

Gurdeep v. State of M.P., AIR 2011 SC 2088: a delay properly explained does not invalidate the FIR.

¶ 20

Vishwanathan v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2008) 2 SCC (Cri) 593: delay alone is not fatal.

¶ 21

State of H.P. v. Rajesh Kumar, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 499: refusal of medical examination by the prosecutrix and family raises a negative inference.

¶ 42

Provisions in the judgment · 20 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 201Section 370Section 375Section 376Section 509

Information Technology Act, 2000 Section 67

Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 11 provisionsSection 3Section 4Section 5Section 6Section 7Section 8Section 9Section 10Section 13Section 14Section 42

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 161Section 164Section 313

04Reasoning

The Court found the prosecution case inconsistent from inception. The written complaint and check FIR, both in the mother's own words, were admittedly dictated by police and based on hearsay, and the mother was not an eye-witness.

¶ 17–18

The victim's accounts escalated across the Section 161 and 164 statements, the FIR, and the trial testimony, which first introduced finger insertion, a multi-incident narrative, and the names of Manoj and Santosh Chauhan. The Court treated these as material improvements that were not explained, and it noted that the mother's own FIR described the acts as spanning "several years" while the victim placed them in 2020–2021.

¶ 23–28

The earlier statements contained no reference to finger insertion, and the medical evidence (three examinations, no external or internal injury, consent refused twice) supplied no corroboration.

¶ 49–51 · ¶ 57–59

The Court applied the Rajesh Kumar negative inference against the family's refusal of internal examination.

¶ 42 · ¶ 50

The video, on which the offences under Sections 376 IPC and 67-B IT Act and POCSO Sections 5(e)/6 and 13/14 rested, was never traced to its source, subjected to FSL examination, or shown to depict the appellant, and the alleged tampering or false information under Section 201 IPC was not established.

¶ 45–46 · ¶ 56 · ¶ 60

The Court found the second I.O.'s fresh investigation was not supported by any recorded justification, which left the possibility of external pressure unexcluded.

¶ 47 · ¶ 59

On the other hand, the Court held that the Section 354-A IPC and Section 9/10 POCSO charges were proved, relying on the victim's core account of touching and the minimal, consistent medical and documentary record for that conduct.

¶ 61 · ¶ 63

The defence witness D.W.-1 was discounted as an employee of the hospital with limited duty hours.

¶ 55

The delay in the FIR was not treated as fatal in itself, but was weighed with the other inconsistencies.

¶ 4 · ¶ 21

05Holding

The Court held that the prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt the offences under Sections 376 and 201 IPC, Section 67-B IT Act, and Sections 5(e)/6 and 13/14 POCSO Act, and that the trial court's findings on these were perverse and unsustainable.

¶ 62

The appeal was partly allowed and the appellant was acquitted of the charges under Sections 376 and 201 IPC, Section 67-B IT Act, and Sections 5(e)/6 and 13/14 POCSO Act.

¶ 64–65

The conviction under Section 354-A IPC and Section 9/10 POCSO Act was confirmed, along with the trial court's sentence under those provisions.

¶ 63–64

All sentences were ordered to run concurrently, with the period of incarceration already undergone adjusted against the substantive sentence.

¶ 66

The trial court records were directed to be sent to the District and Sessions Judge, Bhadohi, for compliance.

¶ 67
Allahabad High Court

Original Court PDF

Shailendra ChauhanvsState Of U.P. And 3 Others

Allahabad High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment