01Facts
The respondent, a Constable, was charged in a departmental proceeding with raping a minor girl. No Presenting Officer was appointed at any stage, but the respondent cross-examined the Department's witnesses, the victim, and her mother.
¶ 3–4The Enquiry Officer found the charges of moral turpitude, gross misconduct, indiscipline and negligence proved, and the Disciplinary Authority imposed compulsory retirement.
¶ 3–4A parallel criminal case (Diphu P.S. Case No. 69/2013, under IPC ss. 336-A/376(f)/34) ended about seven years later in acquittal. The prosecutrix did not support the allegation and did not identify the respondent in the dock. The trial court did not question her or her mother on their earlier statements.
¶ 5The High Court earlier remanded for a reasoned reply to the enquiry report, which the respondent unsuccessfully challenged in W.A. No. 7/2023. That appeal recorded that no Presenting Officer had been appointed.
¶ 6–7On 07.10.2025 the Disciplinary Authority reaffirmed compulsory retirement. The respondent challenged this in W.P.(C) No. 6551/2025, arguing prejudice from the absence of a Presenting Officer, non-consideration of his reply, and entitlement to relief on the "honourable acquittal".
¶ 7–8The learned Single Judge set aside the penalty, ordered reinstatement as Constable with full arrears and back-wages, and directed that he be allowed to serve until retirement, to be complied with within one month.
¶ 2, 902Issues
i.1. Whether the absence of a Presenting Officer in the departmental enquiry vitiated the proceedings and caused prejudice to the respondent.
¶ 20–21ii.2. Whether the respondent's acquittal in the criminal case, recorded after about seven years, warranted setting aside the departmental penalty.
¶ 12, 14, 18iii.3. Whether the criminal acquittal amounted to an "honourable acquittal" entitling the respondent to reinstatement.
¶ 15–17iv.4. Whether the respondent was entitled to full back-wages on reinstatement. (Argued by the State; not separately decided.)
¶ 1303Law Applied
The Court relied on the Single Judge's reliance on Capt. M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Gold Mines Ltd. (1999), G.M. Tank v. State of Gujarat (2006), Ram Lal v. State of Rajasthan (2024), and State Bank of Hyderabad v. P. Kata Rao (2008).
¶ 9A Presenting Officer must ordinarily be appointed in a domestic enquiry, but an enquiry is not vitiated where the delinquent was present, cross-examined witnesses, and understood the charges.
¶ 20On "honourable acquittal," the Court followed Management of Reserve Bank of India v. Bhopal Singh Panchal (1994), Commissioner of Police v. Mehar Singh (2013), State of M.P. v. Parvez Khan (2015), and Imtiyaz Ahmad Malla v. State of J&K (2023). The expression is not synonymous with "fully exonerated," and it applies only where the prosecution has miserably failed after full consideration of its evidence.
¶ 16–17Under Mehar Singh and Parvez Khan, police personnel must have impeccable character and integrity, and even suspicion is fatal to continued service.
¶ 19Back-wages should not be granted automatically on acquittal, as noted in Krishnakant Raghunath Bibhavnekar v. State of Maharashtra (1997), cited by the State.
¶ 13Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 336Section 376Section 34
04Reasoning
The Single Judge's reliance on G.M. Tank and the related authorities was misplaced, because the criminal trial had collapsed on the victim's failure to identify the respondent, while the victim had made a definite disclosure in the departmental enquiry immediately after the occurrence.
¶ 12, 14, 18The trial court's acquittal, recorded seven years after the incident, was not a finding of honourable acquittal, since the trial was not contested robustly and the prosecution's failure rested on non-identification rather than a full evaluation of the evidence.
¶ 5, 17The departmental evidence, including the mother's disclosure and official witnesses' testimony, remained intact and was unaffected by the acquittal.
¶ 18The minor victim's status and the respondent's role as a locally posted policeman called for a higher standard of suitability.
¶ 13, 19On the Presenting Officer issue, the Court accepted that such an appointment is necessary, but found no prejudice because the respondent attended throughout, cross-examined witnesses, and showed full understanding of the charges.
¶ 20–21The penalty of compulsory retirement was a lenient one, with pensionary benefits available.
¶ 19Because the Single Judge's reasoning was found unsustainable, the penalty was restored. The Court did not separately address the back-wages issue.
¶ 2205Holding
(1) The absence of a Presenting Officer did not vitiate the enquiry, as the respondent was not prejudiced.
¶ 20–21(2) The criminal acquittal, recorded many years after the occurrence and based on non-identification, does not justify setting aside the departmental penalty.
¶ 18(3) The acquittal is not an "honourable acquittal" in the relevant sense, since the prosecution did not fail after full evaluation of evidence, and suitability for police service is not negated by acquittal.
¶ 15–17(4) Back-wages were not separately adjudicated.
¶ 13, 22The appeal is allowed. The Single Judge's judgment dated 15.05.2026 in W.P.(C) No. 6551/2025 is set aside, and the penalty of compulsory retirement imposed by the Disciplinary Authority is restored. Costs were recorded as "Cost easy".
¶ 22–24Original Court PDF
The State Of Assam And 4 Ors.vsHabizur Rahman Laskar
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
