01Facts
The appellants, the promoters of the "Hoysala EVM" project, challenged a common order of the Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal in 34 appeals.
¶ 1The first respondents are allottees who filed complaints before K-RERA seeking execution of sale deeds, interest for delay, and other reliefs.
¶ 1The promoters contended that the project was complete, that an Occupancy Certificate (OC) was issued on 10.05.2023 and intimated to allottees, and that the complaints, filed about 1.5 years later, were a response to the promoter's Section 11(5) cancellation steps.
¶ 2The promoters argued that the OC's legality was not for K-RERA to examine.
¶ 2The allottees alleged that the project was not complete, that common areas were not registered to the Association, and that parking slots were not allotted.
¶ 3K-RERA held that the completion relief was not maintainable but that other reliefs were, and treated the project as complete in all respects.
¶ 4The Tribunal set aside that part of the order. It held that K-RERA had breached Regulation 21(4) of the Kerala RERA (General) Regulations, 2020 and Rule 36 of the Kerala RERA Rules, 2018 by inspecting the site through Deputy Directors without notice.
¶ 5The Tribunal also held the completion relief maintainable, distinguished Nidhish P.V., and directed K-RERA to consider the complaints in toto.
¶ 5The promoters appealed.
¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether non-compliance with Regulation 21(4), arising solely from failure to give an opportunity to object to an inspection report, has any legal consequence for a finding that the project is complete on the basis of an OC.
¶ 7(A)ii.2. Whether the Tribunal and K-RERA can disregard an OC issued by the competent authority and rely on other material to find that the project building is complete under the RERA Act.
¶ 7(B)iii.3. Whether the Tribunal can ignore Nidhish P.V. v. Sivaprakash and Siji Jacob v. Ultima Builders and direct K-RERA to adjudicate completion on other material, despite those decisions holding an OC conclusive of completion.
¶ 7(C)iv.4. Whether an appellate authority, on finding a procedural defect, can reopen a finding of completion made on the strength of an OC without recording that the earlier exercise was illegal, without jurisdiction, or otherwise invalid.
¶ 7(D)03Law Applied
The court applied the Kerala Municipality Building Rules, 2019, under which an OC is issued by the municipal Secretary on a completion report (Rules 19C, 20(1), 20(3)–(5)).
¶ 12–13The OC is a creature of local building law and governs only whether the building is built as permitted and fit for occupation.
¶ 14, 17The court applied the RERA Act, 2016, under which the completion and occupancy certificates are defined by reference to local law (Section 2(q), 2(zf)), the promoter must obtain them and make them available (Section 11(4)(b)), and the promoter's further duties relating to conveyance, possession, common areas, interest for delay, defects and complaints arise under Sections 14(3), 17, 18, 11(5) and 31.
¶ 15–16The court relied on Nidhish P.V. v. Sivaprakash (2024 KHC 7050) and Siji Jacob v. Ultima Builders & Developers Pvt. Ltd. (2023 KHC 9214) for the principle that a completion certificate certifies construction per the approved plan, and that its legality can be challenged only through remedies under the governing law, not before RERA authorities.
¶ 9, 19Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. Section 2Section 3Section 11Section 14Section 17Section 18Section 31
04Reasoning
The court separated two meanings of "completion". Under the Building Rules, completion means the building is built per the permit, which the OC conclusively settles. Under the RERA Act, completion also covers whether the promoter has discharged his statutory obligations to allottees, which the OC does not settle.
¶ 18The court held that the legality of the OC, and whether the building is complete per the permit and fit for occupation, cannot be examined by K-RERA or the Tribunal. An allegation of fraud in obtaining the OC does not enlarge their jurisdiction.
¶ 19The allottees' grievances about common areas, parking, conveyance and interest are matters the RERA Act commits to the authorities, and the OC does not bar them.
¶ 20On Question A, the Regulation 21(4) breach arose because the inspection was aimed at a question outside the Authority's jurisdiction. Hence the absence of notice could not justify reopening a finding resting on the OC, and the breach has no consequence for completion.
¶ 21, 22On Questions B and C, the Tribunal erred in permitting an enquiry into completion and in departing from Nidhish and Siji Jacob.
¶ 21–22On Question D, a procedural defect alone does not justify reopening the completion finding.
¶ 2205Holding
The court answered Question A by holding that the Regulation 21(4) breach has no consequence for the completion finding.
¶ 22The court answered Questions B and C in favour of the promoters: the Authority and the Tribunal cannot disregard the OC, and the Tribunal could not depart from Nidhish P.V. and Siji Jacob.
¶ 22The court answered Question D by holding that a procedural defect alone does not justify reopening the completion finding.
¶ 22The court modified the Tribunal's order. It declared that the RERA authorities shall not enquire into the legality of the OC dated 10.05.2023 or whether the building is complete as per the permit and fit for occupation. Subject to that, K-RERA shall proceed with the complaints and adjudicate all other questions under the RERA Act, endeavouring to dispose of them within the timeline fixed in MSA No. 40 of 2026 (judgment dated 11.09.2026).
¶ 22The appeals are disposed of and all pending interlocutory applications are closed.
¶ 22Original Court PDF
M/S HOYSALA PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITEDvsTHAKADIPARAMBIL AUGUSTINE THOMAS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
