01Facts
The plaintiffs sought specific performance of an alleged agreement to sell dated 2 September 2005 for eight kanals of land, asserting that they had paid ₹3,44,000 of the ₹3,64,000 consideration and were ready and willing to pay the balance.
¶ 2The defendant denied executing the agreement and alleged that it was fabricated; he also relied on an earlier alleged agreement concerning the same land, which the plaintiffs had not disclosed in their suit.
¶ 3, 9, 15–16The trial court decreed specific performance, and the first appellate court dismissed the defendant’s appeal. In this second appeal, the High Court examined whether the concurrent findings on execution of the agreement could stand.
¶ 1, 1202Issues
i.Whether the plaintiffs proved due execution of the agreement to sell dated 2 September 2005
¶ 4, issue 1 · ¶ 18–23ii.Whether the plaintiffs established readiness and willingness and were entitled to specific performance
¶ 4, issues 3–4 · ¶ 2, 23iii.Whether the concurrent findings of the courts below were so erroneous or perverse as to warrant interference in a regular second appeal
¶ 1203Law Applied
The party asserting an agreement to sell bears the burden of proving its due execution, and civil claims are assessed on a preponderance of probabilities.
¶ 18–21A High Court in a regular second appeal should not lightly interfere with concurrent factual findings, but may do so where they are erroneous or perverse—for example, because material evidence was not considered, inadmissible evidence was relied upon, or a document was misread.
¶ 12The judgment identifies no specific statutory provision or precedent as the basis for these principles.
04Reasoning
The court found that the agreement contained five unmarked thumb impressions, without identifying their maker or specifying whether they were left or right impressions; some appeared over or on typed text. The plaintiffs did not explain these features or obtain expert evidence to establish that the impressions were the defendant’s.
¶ 13–14, 20–22The court also noted that the second plaintiff had not signed the agreement, the particulars and signature of one attesting witness were unclear, and the scribe was not examined.
¶ 13–14, 20–22Further, the plaintiffs had not disclosed the earlier alleged agreement, the notice relating to it, or why they did not pursue that agreement; the stamp paper for the disputed agreement had been purchased on the earlier agreement’s stated completion date.
¶ 15, 21–22In the court’s view, these circumstances were not addressed by the courts below and left the plaintiffs’ proof insufficient even on a balance of probabilities, rendering the concurrent findings perverse.
¶ 19, 2305Holding
The High Court held that the plaintiffs failed to prove due execution of the agreement dated 2 September 2005 and set aside the finding on that issue.
¶ 23It held that the plaintiffs were not entitled to specific performance, allowed the second appeal, and dismissed the suit.
¶ 23Original Court PDF
Rup RamvsRaj Singh & Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
