Supreme CourtInsolvency and Bankruptcy LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Videocon Creditors Can Revisit Plan After Approval Is Stayed, Supreme Court Says, As Six-Year NCDs Don’t Pay Dissenters

Twinstar Technologies Limitedv.Bank Of Maharashtra

Videocon Creditors Can Revisit Plan After Approval Is Stayed, Supreme Court Says, As Six-Year NCDs Don’t Pay Dissenters. Twinstar Technologies Limited vs Bank Of Maharashtra. Supreme Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether, and within what limits, the NCLT and NCLAT may review a resolution plan approved by the CoC, including whether the NCLAT may remit a plan to the CoC

The court held

The Court dismissed Twinstar’s appeals, upholding the NCLAT’s decision to set aside approval of the resolution plan and remit the matter to the CoC for reconsideration

It also directed

It also dismissed the appeals concerning the foreign oil and gas assets, holding that those assets could not be included in VIL’s CIRP merely because they were held through subsidiaries; the VIL Vendors Association was granted liberty to pursue any remedies available under law

There was no order as to costs

01Facts

The appeals arose from the CIRPs of Videocon Industries Limited (VIL), twelve group companies, and VOVL Limited. In the consolidated CIRP of VIL and the twelve group companies, the CoC approved Twinstar Technologies Limited’s resolution plan by 95.09% of the voting share. The plan provided, among other things, for payment to financial creditors through non-convertible debentures (NCDs), redeemable over several years. The NCLT approved the plan but directed that dissenting financial creditors be paid their liquidation value in cash, upfront. On appeal, the NCLAT set aside the approvals and remitted the matter to the CoC, finding the plan non-compliant with the Code and holding that the CoC could reconsider its decision while the approval remained under challenge

¶ 6–14

A separate group of appeals concerned foreign oil and gas interests held through VIL’s subsidiaries. The NCLT had directed that those assets be included in VIL’s CIRP; the NCLAT later set aside that direction and upheld orders concerning the separate CIRP of VOVL

¶ 30–35

02Issues

i.1. Whether, and within what limits, the NCLT and NCLAT may review a resolution plan approved by the CoC, including whether the NCLAT may remit a plan to the CoC

¶ 23(i)–(ii)

ii.2. Whether the resolution plan complied with Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) and Regulation 38(1)(b) of the CIRP Regulations, and whether the NCLT could cure any deficiency by directing cash payment to dissenting financial creditors

¶ 23(iii)(a)

iii.3. Whether the required approval of the Competition Commission of India (CCI) had been obtained under Section 31(4) of the IBC

¶ 23(iii)(b)

iv.4. Whether the CoC became functus officio after approving the resolution plan and, if not, whether it could revisit its decision while the approval was stayed and under statutory appeal

¶ 23(iv)

v.5. Whether foreign oil and gas assets held through VIL’s subsidiaries could be included in VIL’s CIRP

¶ 45

03Law Applied

Sections 30(2) and 31 of the IBC require a resolution plan to meet statutory conditions before approval; under Section 30(2)(b), dissenting financial creditors must receive at least their liquidation entitlement, while Regulation 38(1)(b) gives them priority over assenting financial creditors.

¶ 24.3

Under Sections 31 and 61(3), the adjudicating and appellate authorities may examine legal compliance but cannot rewrite a plan or substitute their commercial judgment for that of the CoC; where a plan is legally defective, remittal to the CoC may be appropriate (*Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association v. NBCC (India) Ltd.*, *Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta*)

¶ 25–26.1

The CoC remains in existence until implementation of the plan or liquidation and does not become functus officio merely upon approval (*Kalyani Transco v. Bhushan Power and Steel Ltd.*)

¶ 29.1

Section 31(4) requires prior CCI approval where the plan involves a combination under the Competition Act

¶ 28

Sections 18 and 36(4)(d) exclude the assets of a corporate debtor’s Indian or foreign subsidiary from the debtor’s CIRP and liquidation estate; a holding company and subsidiary are distinct legal persons, and the holding company does not own the subsidiary’s assets (*Vodafone International Holdings B.V. v. Union of India*).

¶ 46–48

The corporate veil cannot be lifted to override this statutory exclusion

¶ 55

04Reasoning

The Court held that the plan’s provision for dissenting creditors to receive value through NCDs redeemable over six years did not amount to the monetary “payment” required by Section 30(2)(b), and that the plan did not secure the priority required by Regulation 38(1)(b)

¶ 27.3–27.6

The NCLT’s direction for upfront cash payment altered the plan and was therefore impermissible; the defect had to be considered by the CoC

¶ 27.7

Although the plan was legally non-compliant, the CCI had approved it before CoC voting concluded, satisfying Section 31(4)

¶ 28

Because the approval had been stayed and was under statutory challenge, the CoC had not become functus officio and could reconsider the plan; the NCLAT was entitled to remit it rather than modify it or simply set it aside

¶ 25–26.4, 29.1–29.4

As to the foreign assets, the assets were held through distinct subsidiaries and were therefore excluded from VIL’s CIRP under Section 18’s Explanation; the promoter’s prior conduct also barred him from advancing an inconsistent claim to include them

¶ 49–55

The Court further held that any challenge to alleged improper transfers or guarantees must be brought through the remedies provided by the IBC, rather than by treating subsidiary assets as VIL’s assets

¶ 60

05Holding

The Court dismissed Twinstar’s appeals, upholding the NCLAT’s decision to set aside approval of the resolution plan and remit the matter to the CoC for reconsideration

¶ 71

It also dismissed the appeals concerning the foreign oil and gas assets, holding that those assets could not be included in VIL’s CIRP merely because they were held through subsidiaries; the VIL Vendors Association was granted liberty to pursue any remedies available under law

¶ 60, 72

There was no order as to costs

¶ 71, 72
Supreme Court

Original Court PDF

Twinstar Technologies LimitedvsBank Of Maharashtra

Supreme Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment