01Facts
The petitioner sat for a written examination for the post of Constable (Executive) in the Delhi Police, held in four sets with rearranged questions.
¶ 1The examination was cancelled twice and held a third time; the petitioner appeared in all three rounds.
¶ 2A provisional merit list was issued on 13 July 2015, showing the petitioner as successful, but a revised list on 17 July 2015 awarded an additional mark to candidates above six feet. The petitioner was not entitled to that mark, and the revised cut-off of 71.290 was not met, as he scored 71.264.
¶ 3–6The petitioner and others challenged the answer keys for eight questions (Nos. 17, 55, 56, 71, 75, 79, 86 and 90 of Set C, which corresponded to questions in Set D, the petitioner's set) before the Central Administrative Tribunal in OA 3657/2015.
¶ 7The Tribunal, on 8 January 2016, recorded the Delhi Police's concession of typographical errors and directed an Expert Committee to examine the grievances.
¶ 8The Committee cancelled the eight challenged questions and 13 additional questions.
¶ 9, 22The petitioner's score improved but still fell short of the cut-off.
¶ 10A final result was declared on 22 February 2016 after uniform scaling.
Tribunal's order, quoted at para. 12The petitioner then filed OA 2429/2016, contending that 10 further questions should have been cancelled.
¶ 11The Tribunal dismissed the OA, holding that the Expert Committee's review was comprehensive, that the petitioner had not shown the additional questions were demonstrably incorrect, and that judicial review of expert determinations is limited.
¶ 12, quoting Tribunal paras. 5–10The Tribunal also relied on its judgment in OA 969/2016.
¶ 13The petitioner filed the present writ petition.
¶ 1402Issues
i.1. Whether a candidate who has already challenged a set of answer keys and obtained the Expert Committee's review is barred, by constructive res judicata or the principle of finality, from challenging a fresh set of questions in a subsequent proceeding.
¶ 21 · ¶ 23ii.2. Whether, absent a demonstrable error in the answer key, a Court should examine the correctness of additional questions and answer keys at the instance of an unsuccessful candidate, including on the ground of a Hindi–English mismatch.
¶ 17 · ¶ 19–2003Law Applied
There is no absolute embargo on judicial examination of answer keys, and relief may be granted where a suggested answer is demonstrably unacceptable, with the illustration that an answer of "5" for the sum of 2 and 2 would warrant intervention.
¶ 19Ordinarily, a Court may examine such a challenge to a limited extent.
¶ 20Under the principle of constructive res judicata, a party cannot re-agitate, in a fresh proceeding, grounds that could and should have been raised earlier.
¶ 23There is a need for finality of litigation, so that candidates cannot repeatedly challenge different answers and force re-examination.
¶ 23–24The scope of judicial review is limited where an expert body has examined the issue, and a court will not substitute its own assessment absent mala fides, arbitrariness or perversity.
¶ 12, quoting Tribunal para. 1004Reasoning
The Court accepted that a challenge to answer keys can be entertained in principle but held that this petitioner's case was peculiar: she had "bitten the cherry once".
¶ 18–21In the first proceeding (OA 3657/2015), she had the opportunity to challenge all questions she considered defective but chose to limit her challenge to eight. The Expert Committee addressed those eight and went further, cancelling 13 additional questions, which improved her score. Since she still did not reach the cut-off, the Court held that she could not return with a fresh set of questions, because such a challenge was barred by constructive res judicata.
¶ 22–23The Court reasoned that permitting such challenges would allow endless litigation and require repeated re-constitution of expert committees.
¶ 23–24The Court found no error in the Committee's methodology, noting that its willingness to cancel answers for 13 additional questions showed it acted objectively. The petitioner's Hindi–English mismatch argument was therefore not examined on its merits.
¶ 25 · ¶ 17The Court expressed empathy but held that no further remedy was available in law.
¶ 2605Holding
The petitioner's challenge to the 10 additional questions is barred by constructive res judicata and the need for finality, and the Expert Committee's examination was not shown to be arbitrary or erroneous.
¶ 23, 25–27The Court concurred with the Tribunal's dismissal of OA 2429/2016.
¶ 27The writ petition was dismissed in limine, with no merit found.
¶ 28The Court did not address the connected CM applications separately in the operative paragraphs.
Original Court PDF
Pushpendra KumarvsDelhi Police & Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
