01Facts
The Appellants filed RFA 515/2014 against the decree dated 06.06.2014 in Civil Suit No. 221/2014 (Old No. 160/2003).
¶ 6(a)Original Respondent No. 1 died during the suit, and his LRs were brought on record as Respondents 1(A) to 1(J).
¶ 6(b)Respondents 1(A), 1(B) and 1(G) died during the appeal, on 15.06.2020, 21.06.2023 and 27.12.2024 respectively.
¶ 6(c)–(d)Respondent 1(A) and 1(B)'s deaths were disclosed on 25.11.2024.
¶ 16, 33The Appellants say the LR particulars were supplied on 08.12.2024, and substitution applications (CM 775/2025 and 776/2025) were filed on 07.01.2025.
¶ 16, 33Respondent 1(E) argued the filings were 4 years 206 days and 1 year 200 days after death, and no condonation or setting-aside application was filed.
¶ 8–9For Respondent 1(G), the Appellants say LR particulars arrived by WhatsApp on 10.07.2025 and the application was filed on 13.07.2025 with a supporting Section 5 application (CM 41636/2025) and a counsel's affidavit.
¶ 18, 43, 47Respondent 1(E) relies on the Order dated 24.02.2025, which recorded that the particulars had been supplied.
¶ 10, 44The Registrar allowed all applications by the impugned order dated 20.07.2026.
¶ 3, 6(f)Respondent 1(E), acting in his personal capacity, filed this Chamber Appeal under Chapter II, Rule 5 of the Delhi High Court Rules seeking a declaration that the RFA stood abated.
¶ 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the Registrar was justified in allowing substitution of the LRs of Respondents 1(A) and 1(B) although the applications were filed beyond 90 days of death, given the time limits under Articles 120 and 121 of the Limitation Act.
¶ 26–28, 33–40ii.2. Whether a separate application to set aside abatement was necessary, or whether the substitution prayer could be construed as including that relief.
¶ 32, 35iii.3. Whether the absence of a separate application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act was fatal to the substitution applications.
¶ 36, 39–40iv.4. Whether the delay in substituting the LRs of Respondent 1(G) was sufficiently explained, given the dispute over the date of receipt of LR particulars.
¶ 43–51v.5. Whether Respondent 1(E) had locus to file the Chamber Appeal in his personal capacity.
¶ 54–56vi.6. Whether a declaration that the RFA had abated should be granted.
¶ 5703Law Applied
Order XXII Rules 3, 4 and 10A of the CPC govern substitution on death and the pleader's duty to intimate death.
¶ 27, 29Articles 120 and 121 of the Limitation Act prescribe 90 days for substitution and 60 days for setting aside abatement, with the total outer limit being 150 days from death.
¶ 28 · Om Prakash Gupta alias Lalloowa · ¶ 23Under Binod Pathak v. Shankar Choudhary (2025), a pleader's failure to discharge the Rule 10A duty means the opposite party cannot take advantage of abatement, and the date of communication, not only the date of death, is relevant.
¶ 29–31Under Mithailal Dalsangar Singh v. Annabai Devram Kini (2003) and Om Prakash Gupta alias Lalloowa, a prayer to bring LRs on record may be read as including a prayer to set aside abatement, and a justice-oriented approach applies.
¶ 32Under Sesh Nath Singh v. Baidyabati Sheoraphuli Co-operative Bank Ltd (2021), a formal application under Section 5 is not mandatory, though the Court may require an affidavit or application explaining the delay.
¶ 36Rule 5 of Chapter II of the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 2018 gives an aggrieved person a right of appeal against a Registrar's order within fifteen days.
¶ 55Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5Section 120Section 121
Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 201
04Reasoning
The substitution applications were properly considered by reference to when death was disclosed and when LR particulars were supplied, not merely the dates of death.
¶ 33, 37–39The deaths of Respondents 1(A) and 1(B) were disclosed only on 25.11.2024, and the Appellants filed within about one month of receiving particulars.
¶ 37–38Respondent 1(E) did not dispute these dates; his objections were procedural only.
¶ 34The prayer for substitution could be read as including a prayer to set aside abatement, so a separate application was unnecessary.
¶ 35Section 5 does not require a formal application, and the delay was explained on the record.
¶ 36, 39–40The Court accepted the sworn affidavit of the Appellants' counsel as proof of receipt of LR particulars for Respondent 1(G) on 10.07.2025, and found the Order dated 24.02.2025 insufficient to displace it, since no independent material showed actual receipt earlier.
¶ 47–48Filing within three days of receipt showed diligence.
¶ 49–50Respondent 1(E) was aggrieved because his abatement plea depended on the substitution being refused, so he qualified under Rule 5.
¶ 56Because the impugned order was upheld, the Court found no need to decide the abatement declaration.
¶ 54, 5705Holding
The Registrar's order allowing substitution of the LRs of Respondents 1(A), 1(B) and 1(G) was sustainable. Substitution was not defeated by the 90-day period measured from death, because the relevant period ran from disclosure and receipt of LR particulars.
¶ 40–41, 51–52A separate application to set aside abatement was not required, and the absence of a formal Section 5 application was not fatal. Respondent 1(E) had locus under Rule 5.
¶ 35–36, 40, 56The Chamber Appeal was dismissed and the impugned order of 20.07.2026 was affirmed. The prayer for a declaration that the RFA had abated was not considered. The matter is listed on 17.03.2027 before the Roster Bench for further consideration.
¶ 57–61Original Court PDF
Sh. Kishori Lal & OrsvsSh. Longa Ram (Since Deceased) Though His Lrs & Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
