01Facts
The Appellant (Decree Holder) obtained a money decree dated 11.02.2019 in CS No. 610986/2016 against Puneet Mathur (Judgment Debtor, "JD") for Rs. 3,95,450 with interest.
¶ 7–8JD died during execution. His widow, Smt. Shipra Mathur, was not a party to the suit and was not served.
¶ 9, 27On the Appellant's affidavit that Smt. Shipra Mathur "still holds" the property, the Executing Court attached Flat No. A-2A/84, DDA Flats, Janakpuri (the "Subject Property") on 13.04.2026.
¶ 10The Respondent, JD's sister, filed objections under O. XXI R. 58 CPC, asserting that her father had bequeathed the property to her by a registered Will dated 07.08.2007. The Will permitted JD to construct a second floor at his own cost and reside there, with no right to sell. She further asserted that no second floor had been constructed.
¶ 11–12The Will's final bequest gave "second floor of flat No. A-2A/84… to my son Puneet Mathur".
¶ 37By order dated 19.05.2026, the Executing Court sustained the objections, vacated the attachment, and directed the Appellant to disclose other properties of the JDs.
¶ 14–15The Appellant appealed under s. 96 r/w O. XXI R. 58(4) CPC. The delay of 15 days in re-filing was condoned.
¶ 1–3The appeal was heard at admission with the Appellant's consent and reserved.
¶ 23–2402Issues
i.1. Whether the deceased JD held an interest in the Subject Property that was saleable under s. 60(1) CPC and came to the hands of Smt. Shipra Mathur under s. 50(2) CPC, such that the attachment could be sustained.
¶ 27–28, 35, 56ii.2. Whether the bequest of the "second floor" to JD was absolute, so as to override the restriction on sale in the preceding clause under s. 88 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925.
¶ 38–39, 44–49iii.3. Whether the restriction on alienation is void as repugnant to an absolute grant.
¶ 53–5403Law Applied
Section 50 CPC provides that a decree against a deceased JD may be executed against his legal representative only to the extent of property of the deceased that has come to the representative's hands.
¶ 26–27Section 60(1) CPC renders liable to attachment only saleable property, or property over which the JD has a disposing power exercisable for his own benefit.
¶ 28–29Order XXI Rule 58(2) and (4) CPC provide that questions of right, title and interest in attached property are determined in execution, and the order has the force of a decree (L.K. Prabhu v. K.T. Mathew, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2577).
¶ 30–32An attaching creditor takes only the JD's right, title and interest, and no higher right (Vannarakkal Kallalathil Sreedharan v. Chandramaath Balakrishnan, (1990) 3 SCC 291).
¶ 33–34Under ss. 82, 87 and 88 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, a Will is read as a whole, and the later of two clauses prevails only where they are irreconcilable (Kaivelikkal Ambunhi v. H. Ganesh Bhandary, (1995) 5 SCC 444; Maj. Gen. Rajinder Singh Chowdhary v. S. Manjit Singh Chowdhary, 2000 SCC OnLine Del 724 (FB); Shakuntla v. Rajinder Singh Deswal, 2025:DHC:7048-DB).
¶ 39–43An absolute grant with a restriction on alienation is valid and the restriction void, but this rule applies only to absolute grants (Gopala Menon v. Sivaraman Nair, (1981) 3 SCC 586).
¶ 53–54Section 6(d) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 bars transfer of an interest restricted to the owner personally.
¶ 59Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151Section 96Section 47Section 50Section 60
Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 82Section 87Section 88
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 53Section 6
04Reasoning
The Court held that the Will, read as a whole, does not bequeath an absolute estate in the second floor to JD. The preceding clause sets out the Testator's scheme in detail: the property devolves on the Respondent, and JD receives a limited right to construct and reside, with no power of sale.
¶ 46–47The Court found no irreconcilable conflict between the two clauses, so s. 88 was not engaged, and the construction urged by the Appellant would render the restriction on sale otiose.
¶ 47–49Placing itself in the Testator's "armchair," the Court relied on the recitals that JD had caused financial loss, had attempted to sell the flat fraudulently, and had been disowned by public notice. It held that an absolute, alienable estate in the second floor was inconsistent with the Testator's intention.
¶ 50–52The rule in Gopala Menon does not apply because no absolute grant existed from which the restriction could be severed.
¶ 53–54The right so conferred was personal and inalienable, and therefore neither saleable under s. 60(1) CPC nor property that came to Smt. Shipra Mathur under s. 50(2) CPC.
¶ 57–59Independently, the Will and the Respondent's objections recorded that the second floor had never been built. The Appellant offered no evidence to the contrary and bore the burden of establishing an attachable interest. The unexercised permission to build created no attachable structure or estate.
¶ 60–63The Court also rejected the plea that the decree would be rendered unsatisfiable, noting that this could not justify attaching non-attachable property and that the Appellant could pursue other property.
¶ 6605Holding
The deceased JD held no saleable interest in the Subject Property that came to Smt. Shipra Mathur, and the Subject Property was therefore not liable to attachment in whole or in part.
¶ 64The Will conferred on JD only a personal, non-alienable right to construct and reside on the unbuilt second floor, and s. 88 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 did not apply.
¶ 68–69The Executing Court was correct in sustaining the objections under O. XXI R. 58 and vacating the attachment dated 13.04.2026. The appeal was dismissed and the impugned order dated 19.05.2026 upheld.
¶ 70–71The Appellant may proceed against other properties of the JDs, or against any property of the deceased shown to have come to his legal representatives. The application for condonation of delay (CM APPL. 70594/2026) was allowed. No order as to costs.
¶ 3, 72, 74Original Court PDF
Tilak RajvsShikha Mathur
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
