01Facts
The respondent, Ahluwalia Contracts (India) Ltd., issued Work Order No. ACIL/RKMCH/WO/2021/20 dated 01.05.2021 to the petitioner, Janvee Contracts Pvt. Ltd., for concrete mixing, transportation and pumping at a medical college project in Hamirpur, valued at Rs. 1,99,20,000.
¶ 2Annexure-III, under the heading "Arbitration and Resolution of Dispute," contains Clause 18 (disputes "will be resolved amicably in consultation with Chairman-ACIL," whose "decision shall be final and binding") and Clause 19 (Delhi courts have "exclusive jurisdiction").
¶ 3The petitioner claims Rs. 19,30,000, comprising Rs. 9,25,186 due per ledger, Rs. 4,61,254 security deposit, and 15% interest.
¶ 4The respondent's Chairman had earlier stated in March 2024 that nothing was due.
¶ 5After a notice under Section 21 dated 28.07.2025 invoking Clause 18, the respondent replied on 23.08.2025 denying liability and the existence of any arbitration agreement, describing Clause 18 as an internal dispute resolution mechanism.
¶ 6A pre-institution mediation on a different project failed.
¶ 7The petitioner sought appointment of a sole arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the A&C Act.
¶ 1The execution of the Work Order and the text of Clauses 18–19 are undisputed.
¶ 1502Issues
i.1. Whether Clause 18 of the Work Order dated 01.05.2021 constitutes an arbitration agreement within the meaning of Section 7 of the A&C Act, so as to permit appointment of an arbitrator under Section 11(6).
¶ 1203Law Applied
The court's examination under Section 11 is limited to the prima facie existence of an arbitration agreement, as held in SBI General Insurance v. Krish Spinning and In re Interplay.
¶ 13–14Section 7 requires an agreement to submit present or future disputes to arbitration, which may be in the form of a contract clause.
¶ 16The attributes of an arbitration agreement, including binding decision, adjudication by a tribunal, a judicial and impartial process and enforceability, were laid down in K.K. Modi v. K.N. Modi.
¶ 17Jagdish Chander v. Ramesh Chander holds that the intention must be gathered from the terms, the words must show a determination and obligation to arbitrate rather than a mere possibility, the heading is not decisive, and clauses that detract from arbitral attributes are not arbitration agreements.
¶ 18Mahanadi Coalfields holds that a company-level dispute mechanism titled "Settlement of Disputes/Arbitration" is not an arbitration agreement.
¶ 19South Delhi Municipal Corporation v. SMS Ltd. (2026) 1 SCC 545 requires clear intent to arbitrate, a binding adjudicatory process and compliance with arbitral norms, all conjunctively; finality alone, or referral to an officer of one party, does not suffice.
¶ 20Rukmanibai Gupta, Punjab State v. Dina Nath and Jhankar Banquets recognise arbitration where a named authority is to decide disputes, without express use of the word "arbitration."
¶ 21The decisive test is whether the clause discloses an obligation to submit disputes to an adjudicatory process, as distinct from a mechanism aimed at amicable settlement.
¶ 22Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 7Section 8Section 11Section 21
04Reasoning
The court held that Clause 18 provides only for amicable resolution "in consultation with" the respondent's Chairman. It does not refer disputes to him for adjudication, does not describe him as an arbitrator, and provides no procedure for submission of claims, hearing or evidence.
¶ 23, 27"Resolved amicably" and "in consultation with" denote consensual settlement, not adjudication, and the clause does not provide for any subsequent reference to arbitration.
¶ 24The "final and binding" phrase could not be read in isolation; finality attaches to the outcome but does not establish an arbitral process, and the decision was intended as part of an amicable mechanism.
¶ 25–26The Chairman is an officer of the respondent itself, which indicates an internal, company-level mechanism, as in Mahanadi Coalfields.
¶ 28The heading "Arbitration and Resolution of Dispute" was not decisive, since the operative words do not refer to arbitration and the same heading governs Clause 19, which deals with court jurisdiction.
¶ 29–32Clause 19, vesting exclusive jurisdiction in Delhi courts over "all matters arising out of this contract," was held consistent with the absence of an intention to arbitrate.
¶ 33Distinguishing Rukmanibai and Dina Nath, the court noted that those clauses required a reference "for orders" or decision by a named authority, whereas Clause 18 contains no such reference.
¶ 34Accordingly, the essential attributes of an arbitration agreement were absent.
¶ 3505Holding
Clause 18 does not constitute an arbitration agreement under Section 7 of the A&C Act. It provides only for amicable resolution in consultation with the respondent's Chairman, and its finality language does not convert it into an arbitral mechanism.
¶ 35(a)–(b)Since no arbitration agreement exists, the court cannot appoint an arbitrator under Section 11(6). The petition is dismissed. The petitioner is at liberty to pursue remedies available in law, and nothing in the order expresses any opinion on the merits of the claims or defence.
¶ 36, 37, 38Original Court PDF
Janvee Contracts Pvt Ltd (Jcpl)vsAhluwalia Contracts (India) Ltd. (Acil)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
