01Facts
Forty-three petitioners were initially appointed as Home Guards under the Assam Home Guard Act and Rules, 1947, and later as Special Police Officers (SPOs) under the Assam Police Act, 2007.
¶ 2Pursuant to the Additional DGP's direction dated 25.07.2012 and communication dated 01.08.2012 approving deployment of 1,200 ex-Home Guards as SPOs in the Bodoland Territorial Council area, they were engaged as SPOs.
¶ 2They were later discharged (order dated 07.06.2016), and 1,200 Home Guards were released by order dated 07.04.2018.
¶ 1, 2, 6Earlier, in WP(C) No. 7479/2022, the Court (order dated 23.11.2022) directed that their representations be disposed of by the DGP or Home Secretary, Assam.
¶ 3The representation was instead decided by the Inspector General of Police, who rejected re-employment by order dated 25.08.2023, relying on State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi.
¶ 4The petitioners contended that the IGP was not the competent authority.
¶ 7, 12A recruitment advertisement for 5,563 Constable posts (with 1% reservation each for Home Guards and SPOs) was issued on 06.10.2023; an interim order dated 15.11.2023 kept posts vacant for the petitioners.
¶ 10–11, 22The State contended that SPO appointments are honorary and made under s. 23 of the 2007 Act, and that the petitioners could participate in the fresh recruitment with a 10-year age relaxation.
¶ 13–14Most petitioners did participate, per the interim liberty of 18.10.2023.
¶ 16, 2002Issues
i.1. Whether the IGP's disposal of the representation, contrary to the direction that the DGP or Home Secretary decide it, is sustainable, given the competency objection was not pleaded.
¶ 18ii.2. Whether the impugned order dated 25.08.2023 rejecting re-employment is legally sustainable, particularly in light of Uma Devi and the petitioners' claim that their initial appointments were regular.
¶ 8, 19iii.3. Whether the petitioners are entitled to re-induction or regularization as SPOs or equivalent posts.
¶ 19, 21iv.4. Whether the petitioners' candidatures for the 06.10.2023 recruitment should be considered, and in what manner.
¶ 21–2303Law Applied
Section 23 of the Assam Police Act, 2007 permits appointment of SPOs by the Superintendent of Police, with State approval, only where a disturbance requires supplementary force, for a period specified in the appointment order, and makes SPO service honorary.
¶ 19The Assam Home Guard Act and Rules, 1947 establish that Home Guard appointments are for a particular period.
¶ 19Bharat Singh v. State of Haryana, AIR 1988 SC 2181 holds that a point of law dependent on facts must be pleaded with supporting material in the writ petition or counter-affidavit and cannot be raised in oral argument.
¶ 12, 18State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi was referred to as the basis for the IGP's rejection of re-employment.
¶ 4, 19The petitioners relied on Nihal Singh v. State of Punjab, (2013) 14 SCC 65, and on the argument that Uma Devi does not apply to non-illegal appointments made through due process; the State distinguished Nihal Singh on the ground of a much shorter service period.
¶ 8–9, 14Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Assam Police Act, 2007 Section 6Section 23
04Reasoning
The Court rejected the competency challenge to the IGP's order because it was not pleaded and is intrinsically factual, so it could not be raised in oral argument under Bharat Singh.
¶ 18The Court held that the petitioners' initial entry was not disputed, but the statutory framework controls: Home Guard and SPO appointments are time-bound, and s. 23 limits SPO induction to specific emergencies and durations.
¶ 19Since SPO service is not permanent by statute, a direction for re-induction would be inconsistent with the Act's objective.
¶ 21The Court nonetheless noted that there was no blemish in the petitioners' service and that most had participated in the 2023 Constable recruitment.
¶ 21Given the large number of vacancies (5,563 posts) and the earlier order keeping posts vacant, the Court found it appropriate to direct consideration of their candidatures, taking into account their experience as Home Guards and SPOs, on par with similarly situated persons.
¶ 22–2305Holding
The petitioners cannot claim re-induction or regularization as SPOs, as SPO appointment under s. 23 of the Assam Police Act, 2007 is temporary and honorary.
¶ 19, 21The Court directed that the petitioners' candidatures be considered in the proper perspective, taking into account their experience as SPOs and Home Guards, at par with similarly situated persons. The writ petition was disposed of accordingly, with no order as to costs. The judgment does not expressly set aside the impugned discharge, termination, or speaking orders, and it does not decide the IGP-competency issue on merits.
¶ 18, 23, 24–26, 25Original Court PDF
Srimanta Das And 42 Ors.vsThe State Of Assam And 15 Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
