01Facts
The respondent, Udit Gupta, joined BSNL as an Assistant Executive Engineer (Civil) in 1992 and was given ad-hoc promotion to Superintending Engineer (Civil) in 2005
¶ 5He was never regularly promoted because his APARs/ACRs carried "below the benchmark" remarks. The Recruitment Rules of 2009 required "very good" grading, "not adverse" remarks, and not more than one "good" for regular promotion
¶ 5His challenges to these gradings had failed, except for a Madras CAT direction to BSNL to pass a speaking order
¶ 6The Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, found that he had topped his batch and was denied time-bound promotion solely because of the APAR gradings, and that he was a whistle-blower. It therefore applied Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Union of India, (1997) 11 SCC 112
¶ 6By order dated 19.07.2024 in O.A. No. 040/251/2017, the Tribunal directed BSNL to hold a review DPC to consider the respondent for early/antedated promotion
¶ 2BSNL challenged that order in the present writ petition. Its grounds included that the challenge was filed belatedly after juniors had been promoted and many had retired, and that antedating would disturb the seniority of about 40 persons who had not been impleaded
¶ 9It also argued that Shiv Kumar Sharma was decided in special circumstances and cannot be applied automatically to BSNL, which follows its own promotion rules
¶ 10The respondent was later promoted to Chief Engineer and has since retired
¶ 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in directing a review DPC for antedated promotion of the respondent by applying the grading-elevation principle in Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Union of India
¶ 2, 6–8 · pp. 2–4ii.2. Whether such antedated promotion can be granted at this stage, when the respondent has retired and the proposed exercise would disturb the seniority of already-promoted and retired employees
¶ 9, 11 · pp. 4–503Law Applied
The Court relied on Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Union of India, (1997) 11 SCC 112, which accepted the Full Bench CAT suggestion that, where employees shouldered higher-class responsibilities, their gradings for that period should be treated as one level higher than those actually awarded, to meet the ends of justice, and which indicated that UPSC acceptance of such a suggestion would settle the matter
¶ 7 · pp. 3–4The Court also reflected the principle that a retiree's settled seniority should not be unsettled through a belated and meaningless exercise
¶ 11 · p. 5The governing service framework is the BSNL Recruitment Rules of 2009, which prescribe "very good," "not adverse," and no more than one "good" grading as the eligibility for regular promotion to Superintending Engineer
¶ 5 · p. 2BSNL's own promotion rules, which are followed to the letter, were treated as governing the case and not displaced automatically by external precedent
¶ 10 · pp. 4–504Reasoning
The Tribunal's reliance on Shiv Kumar Sharma was based on the respondent's topper status, his whistle-blower status, and the fact that his denial of promotion rested only on APAR gradings. The Tribunal then re-graded him one level higher and concluded that he might have qualified when his juniors were promoted
¶ 6, 8 · pp. 3–4The Division Bench did not accept that this justified the relief. It held that Shiv Kumar Sharma arose in separate special circumstances and could not be applied automatically to a BSNL employee governed by its own rules
¶ 10 · pp. 4–5The Court's decisive reasoning is practical. The respondent had since been promoted to Chief Engineer and had retired, so a review DPC for antedated promotion to Superintending Engineer would be meaningless. It would also unnecessarily disturb the seniority of retired employees
¶ 11 · p. 5The Court did not expressly adopt BSNL's argument about the approximately 40 non-impleaded employees whose seniority would be affected, but its finding that the exercise would disturb a settled pecking order rests on the same concern
¶ 9, 11 · pp. 4–5The Court also accepted that the directions were not tenable
¶ 12 · p. 505Holding
The Court answered both issues against the respondent. Applying the Shiv Kumar Sharma grading-elevation principle to order a review DPC for antedated promotion was not tenable in the circumstances, given BSNL's own promotion rules, the respondent's subsequent promotion and retirement, and the resulting disturbance of settled seniority
¶ 10–12 · pp. 4–5The Division Bench set aside the Tribunal's order dated 19.07.2024 in O.A. No. 040/251/2017 and allowed WP(C)/372/2025. No directions for a review DPC survive
¶ 13 · p. 5Original Court PDF
The Chairman Cum Manging Director Bsnl And AnrvsUdit Gupta
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
