01Facts
The workman was appointed as a daily-rated permanent worker on 28.07.1981, promoted to Sardar (w.e.f. 02.01.1984), made a driver (w.e.f. 01.04.1986), and upgraded to Artisan Grade-B (w.e.f. 01.09.2001).
¶ 3A PF nomination form dated 05.09.1985 recorded his date of birth as 1950.
¶ 4On 02.06.2008 the management informed him that his service would end on superannuation w.e.f. 30.06.2008; gratuity was sanctioned and he was offered re-employment w.e.f. 01.07.2008, renewable six-monthly, which he accepted.
¶ 4He received provident fund settlements on 05.10.2009 and a further sum on 31.03.2011, and signed a pensionary benefits statement on 06.06.2011.
¶ 5He raised a dispute on 05.12.2011, asserting a date of birth of 31.10.1956 and superannuation on 31.10.2014.
¶ 6The judgment later refers to the dispute as raised on 15.12.2011.
¶ 15, 20, 24The State referred the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal, Cachar, on 12.02.2014.
¶ 6The Tribunal, by Award dated 02.03.2016, held the date of birth to be 31.10.1956, found the PF nomination form unproved, and held the workman entitled to benefits up to 31.10.2014 but not to compensation.
¶ 9The management filed WP(C) No. 4053/2017 on 07.07.2017.
¶ 10The workman died during the pendency; his wife, son and daughter were substituted.
¶ 12The substituted respondents produced a Staff Register showing date of birth 31.10.1956, which was not before the Tribunal.
¶ 13, 22The workman admitted in cross-examination that he never submitted any date-of-birth certificate after his appointment.
¶ 2102Issues
i.1. Whether the Industrial Tribunal's finding that the workman's date of birth was 31.10.1956, and not 1950 as recorded in the PF nomination form, is sustainable or perverse, such that it warrants interference under Article 226.
¶ 9, 20, 24ii.2. Whether the workman, having accepted the superannuation date of 30.06.2008, the gratuity, provident fund and pensionary benefits, and re-employment, is estopped from disputing his date of birth and superannuation date.
¶ 20, 23–2403Law Applied
The Court relied on the principle that a date of birth recorded in service records and accepted throughout service cannot be altered at the fag end of service, and that an application for change is not a matter of right and may be rejected for delay and laches, particularly when made near superannuation, citing Karnataka Rural Infrastructure Development Ltd. v. T.P. Nataraja, (2021) 12 SCC 27, as quoted in General Manager, Barsua Iron Ore Mines v. Vice President, United Mines Mazdoor Union (2024 INSC 264), paras. 18–21.
¶ 20 · ¶ 23–24The Court applied the estoppel principle from Barsua Iron Ore Mines, drawing on Union of India v. C. Rama Swamy, (1997) 4 SCC 647, which holds that relief cannot be granted where the candidate earlier represented a different date of birth for his advantage.
¶ 19, 21, 23The settled rule, from Management of Madurantakam Coop. Sugar Mills v. S. Viswanathan, (2005) 3 SCC 193, as cited by the respondents, is that the High Court under Article 226 interferes with a Labour Tribunal award only where it is perverse on the face of the record.
¶ 17 · ¶ 2404Reasoning
The Court found that the workman was informed of his 30.06.2008 superannuation in advance and did not object.
¶ 20He then accepted gratuity, provident fund dues and pensionary benefits, signed a pension-related statement, and accepted re-employment on six-monthly terms, all without objection.
¶ 20, 24The dispute was raised only after these benefits were received.
¶ 20, 24The workman's own evidence also established that he never submitted a date-of-birth certificate during service.
¶ 21Against this conduct, the Tribunal's reliance on the unproved PF nomination form, while overlooking the workman's conduct, was held to be a failure to consider vital aspects bearing on estoppel.
¶ 24That omission rendered the Award perverse, and the Court therefore did not need to decide the date of birth on the merits.
¶ 24The Court followed Barsua Iron Ore Mines, where a workman who had accepted a date of birth for a long period was held estopped from later changing it.
¶ 23The Court did not separately address the petitioner's argument that no industrial dispute survived the cessation of the employer-workman relationship.
¶ 1405Holding
The Court held that the Tribunal's Award dated 02.03.2016 was perverse because it ignored the workman's acceptance of the 1950 date of birth and of the 30.06.2008 superannuation, along with his acceptance of benefits and re-employment, which together raised the principle of estoppel.
¶ 24–25The Award was set aside and quashed.
¶ 25(i)No order as to costs was made, and the TCR was ordered to be returned.
¶ 25(ii), 25(iii)Original Court PDF
M/S. Kalline Tea EstatevsOn The Death Of Amol Tanti His Legal Heir Smti Anurupa Tanti
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
