01Facts
The petitioner was selected for the post of Civil Police Constable in a 2019 recruitment process.
¶ 3–4After the Tribunal directed the State to consider his appointment, the State delayed implementation of that order; an appointment order was eventually issued on 1 January 2025, directing him to report on 9 January 2025.
¶ 3–4, 10–11In the meantime, the petitioner had been injured in an accident on 30 November 2024, resulting in the amputation of his leg.
¶ 5He sought an alternative post, but the Police Department rejected his request on the grounds that he was physically unfit for constable duties and had been selected only for that post.
¶ 5, 14–14.1The Tribunal dismissed his challenge.
¶ 6, 14.2He then petitioned the High Court, seeking consideration for suitable alternative employment.
¶ 6, 14.202Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner could be appointed as a Civil Police Constable despite no longer meeting the prescribed physical standards.
¶ 17ii.2. Whether, in light of the petitioner’s successful selection, the State’s delay in implementing the Tribunal’s order, and his intervening disability, the State should be required to consider him for a suitable alternative post.
¶ 17, 24–3003Law Applied
Under Articles 226, 14 and 16 of the Constitution, sympathy alone cannot create a right to public employment or justify an appointment contrary to applicable recruitment rules.
¶ 18–19, 22, 25–26, 34However, where the legal framework permits a reasonable administrative response, the State—as a constitutional employer—must act fairly, reasonably and without arbitrariness.
¶ 18–19, 22, 25–26, 34A court may require meaningful consideration of an alternative appointment where the circumstances warrant it, without diluting the requirements for the originally advertised post or directing an appointment contrary to law.
¶ 18–19, 22, 25–26, 34The Court cited no specific precedent or statutory provision governing alternative appointment.
04Reasoning
The petitioner could not be appointed as a constable because he no longer met the physical standards for that post.
¶ 17, 24–25But his claim arose not from disability alone: he had succeeded in the selection process, obtained a binding Tribunal order in his favour, and remained without an appointment within the time directed because of the State’s delay.
¶ 20–21, 27–28Although the State was not responsible for the accident, it could not disregard the consequences of its own delay or refuse even to consider an alternative post.
¶ 15–16, 25–31The Court therefore held that the State must assess whether an appropriate appointment was permissible under the applicable rules, having regard to the petitioner’s qualifications and present physical capacity.
¶ 15–16, 25–3105Holding
The High Court allowed the writ petition and set aside the Tribunal’s order.
¶ 37(i)–(ii)It directed the State to meaningfully consider the petitioner for a desk job, in light of the circumstances discussed in the judgment, within eight weeks of receiving a copy of the order.
¶ 37(iii), (v)The direction did not create an automatic right to alternative public employment or authorize an appointment contrary to the governing rules.
¶ 34Original Court PDF
SRI SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATHvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
