01Facts
The workman, a BMTC conductor, was charged after a checking squad found 12 passengers travelling without tickets on his bus.
pp. 2–4, 6The Corporation alleged that he had collected fares from four passengers but not issued tickets, and had neither issued tickets nor collected fares from the other eight.
pp. 2–4, 6No departmental enquiry was held; the disciplinary authority imposed a penalty of reduction of one annual increment with cumulative effect and treated the suspension period as suspension.
pp. 2–4, 6On the workman’s industrial dispute, the Industrial Tribunal set aside the penalty.
pp. 2–4, 6The Corporation challenged that award under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
pp. 2–4, 602Issues
i.1. Whether, where no departmental enquiry was conducted, the Corporation proved the charges against the workman before the Tribunal
pp. 4–6ii.2. Whether the Tribunal’s award setting aside the penalty disclosed an error or illegality warranting interference under Articles 226 and 227
p. 703Law Applied
Where an employer conducts no domestic enquiry and disputes the charges, the employer bears the burden of proving them before the Tribunal by adducing evidence.
pp. 6–7The Corporation relied on The Managing Director, North East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation v. Shivayananamath, 2003 AIR-Kant. 1653, but the Court did not apply or discuss that precedent in its reasoning.
p. 4No specific statutory provision was identified as the basis of the decision.
04Reasoning
Because no departmental enquiry had been held, the Corporation had to prove the charges before the Tribunal.
pp. 6–7It did not examine the checking officials who inspected the bus and made the report, or produce other evidence substantiating the allegations.
pp. 6–7The workman denied the charges.
pp. 6–7The Court therefore upheld the Tribunal’s finding that the charges were unproved and found no basis to interfere with its award.
pp. 6–705Holding
The Court held that the Tribunal committed no error or illegality in setting aside the penalty.
p. 7It dismissed the Corporation’s writ petition as devoid of merit.
p. 7Original Court PDF
DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER BMTCvsSRI HANUMANTHARAJU
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
