01Facts
The petitioner and the opposite party (OP) were acquainted from August 2008, when both worked at Aviva Life Insurance; the OP resigned in 2009 but the parties remained in contact.
¶ 2, 12–13The OP alleges that in January 2021 the petitioner sent messages about his unhappy marriage and requested a meeting; that on 17.04.2021 he requested sex and made unwelcome physical contact; and that on 19.04.2021 he asked her to delete messages because his wife had discovered his affairs, threatening to defame her family if she refused.
¶ 3, 13The OP's complaint was lodged on 09.02.2022.
¶ 15, 23The petitioner's wife lodged Survey Park PS Case No. 167 of 2021 on 14.09.2021 against the OP for abusive and threatening messages, under Sections 506(II)/509/120B IPC.
¶ 14–15The OP obtained bail on 29.10.2021 and a charge sheet was filed on 31.01.2022.
¶ 15, 23Nine days later the OP filed the present complaint (AC 347/2022) under Sections 354A and 506 IPC.
¶ 3, 15In her initial deposition under Section 200 CrPC, the OP described a love affair and a marriage proposal from the petitioner, which her complaint did not mention.
¶ 4, 16, 24The Magistrate took cognizance on 09.02.2022 and issued process on 30.03.2022.
¶ 7, 15The petitioner sought quashing under Section 482 CrPC / Section 528 BNSS.
¶ 8–11The OP contended that the material raised disputed questions of fact unsuitable for summary determination.
¶ 8–1102Issues
i.1. Whether the allegations in the complaint and the contemporaneous WhatsApp messages prima facie constitute sexual harassment under Section 354A IPC, namely sexually coloured remarks or unwelcome sexual overtures.
¶ 18–21ii.2. Whether the allegations prima facie constitute criminal intimidation under Section 506 IPC.
¶ 18, 27–30iii.3. Whether the complaint is a malicious counterblast to the wife's FIR and warrants quashing in light of the delay, suppression, and contradictory versions.
¶ 22–26iv.4. Whether the cognizance and process orders dated 09.02.2022 and 30.03.2022 reflect a non-application of judicial mind.
¶ 7, 3103Law Applied
Section 354A IPC defines sexual harassment to include physical contact and advances involving unwelcome explicit sexual overtures, demands for sexual favours, and making sexually coloured remarks.
¶ 17Sections 503 and 506 IPC: criminal intimidation requires a threat of injury with intent to cause alarm, or to compel an act or omission, and a bare allegation of "threatened" is insufficient without that intent.
¶ 27–30Under Iqbal @ Bala v. State of U.P., (2023) 8 SCC 734, and Md. Ali v. State of U.P., 2023 SCC OnLine SC 950, the court may look beyond the complaint's averments to attending circumstances and "read in between the lines" where a complaint is drafted to disclose ingredients but is motivated by ulterior purpose.
¶ 26Pepsi Food Ltd. v. Special Judicial Magistrate, (1998) 5 SCC 749, holds that the High Court may quash a complaint disclosing no case, even where the Magistrate could later discharge the accused.
¶ 31Rule 183 of the Calcutta High Court Criminal Rules and Orders requires judicial application of mind at cognizance.
¶ 31State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335, illustrations 1, 3, 5 and 7 cover complaints that do not disclose an offence, uncontroverted allegations that disclose no offence, inherently improbable allegations, and mala fide or vengeful proceedings.
¶ 32Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 506Section 509Section 204Section 503
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 200Section 482Section 245
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528
Essential Commodities Act, 1955 Section 3
04Reasoning
On Section 354A, the OP's own initial deposition admitted a love relationship, and the annexed WhatsApp messages showed regular, mutually participatory exchanges.
¶ 19Nothing in the replies showed discomfort or a cautionary response rejecting the sexual content.
¶ 19Since the parties had a relationship from 2008, the intimate conversations occurring within that relationship could not be retrospectively classified as sexual harassment merely because the relationship later failed.
¶ 20On Section 506, the complaint alleged a demand to delete messages and non-disclosure, but neither the complaint nor the deposition alleged an intent to cause alarm or that the OP was alarmed, so the essential ingredients of Section 503 were not satisfied.
¶ 30The wife's FIR preceded the complaint, and the OP filed it nine days after the charge sheet, after an unexplained delay of about eight months from the last alleged incident.
¶ 23The complaint suppressed the prior relationship and the FIR's allegations, and the OP's accounts of the relationship were inconsistent.
¶ 23–25Applying Iqbal and Md. Ali, the Court found the complaint to be a counterblast filed to implicate the petitioner and arm-twist withdrawal of the FIR.
¶ 23, 25–26On cognizance, the Magistrate used a cyclostyled order, filled in blanks, and did not specify the offences, which showed non-application of mind contrary to Rule 183.
¶ 31Relying on Pepsi Food, the High Court could intervene because the complaint disclosed no offence, and the Magistrate's cognizance order was not an impediment.
¶ 31The Court rejected the OP's argument that the matter involved disputed facts requiring trial, because the defects appeared from the complaint and the admitted record.
¶ 26, 31–32Bhajan Lal illustrations 1, 3, 5 and 7 were held applicable.
¶ 3205Holding
The complaint did not disclose the ingredients of sexual harassment under Section 354A IPC or criminal intimidation under Section 506 IPC.
¶ 26, 30The proceeding was a mala fide counterblast to the wife's FIR.
¶ 26, 32CRR 2633 of 2022 is allowed.
¶ 33Complaint case No. AC 347 of 2022 pending before the learned ACJM, Alipore, is quashed in its entirety.
¶ 34Original Court PDF
JOHN MAYNEvsDEVAPRIYA MUKHERJEE
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
