Bombay High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Bombay HC Upholds Setting Aside Of RERA Freeze On Chembur Redevelopment: Buyers Of Terminated Developer Can't Claim Against Society

Afzal Alarakha Mansuriv.Chembur Shivmurti Co Operative Housing Society Through Its Secretary Mr. Vijay C.Sharma

Bombay HC Upholds Setting Aside Of RERA Freeze On Chembur Redevelopment: Buyers Of Terminated Developer Can't Claim Against Society. Afzal Alarakha Mansuri vs Chembur Shivmurti Co Operative Housing Society Through Its Secretary Mr. Vijay C.Sharma. Bombay High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether, in view of the RERA, 2016 (Sections 15 and 18), third-party allottees of an erstwhile developer can enforce substantive rights against the Society after termination of the development agreement, notwithstanding the Vaidehi Akash line of decisions.

The court held

Issue 1 is answered against the complainants: third-party purchasers from the erstwhile developer cannot enforce substantive rights against the Society or its assets, and their remedy lies against the erstwhile developer.

It also directed

Issue 2 is answered in the negative: the non-reasoned Supreme Court order in Sandeep Grover lays down no law that overrules the Vaidehi Akash line, and the Tribunal was not disregarding a binding Supreme Court precedent.

Issue 3 is held against the complainants, as the Authority's order was legally unsustainable.

It is held that no substantial question of law arises.

The Second Appeals are dismissed, the interim applications, if any, are disposed of, and there is no order as to costs.

01Facts

The Chembur Shivmurti Cooperative Housing Society ("the Society") owns Building No. 22 at Subhash Nagar, Chembur. It appointed G.A. Builders Pvt. Ltd. ("the erstwhile developer") under a development agreement dated 25 October 2007.

¶ 2.3

The erstwhile developer defaulted on the redevelopment, abandoned a partly constructed structure, and failed to pay transit rent.

¶ 2.4 · ¶ 38

The Society terminated the agreement on 8 August 2019 and appointed Adityaraj Housing Corporation ("the new developer").

¶ 2.4–2.5

This Court's orders under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 restrained the erstwhile developer from obstructing the redevelopment.

¶ 2.6 · ¶ 14

An Arbitral Tribunal's order under Section 17 directed removal of the erstwhile developer's articles and machinery, and this Court upheld it.

¶ 2.7 · ¶ 15

The termination's validity remained pending before the Arbitral Tribunal.

¶ 16

The complainants are purported allottees who bought units in the sale component from the erstwhile developer.

¶ 2.9

A Division Bench of this Court in Writ Petition (L) No. 1776 of 2023 held that such third-party purchasers could not enforce substantive rights against the Society.

¶ 2.9 · ¶ 18–19

The NCDRC proceedings were pending, and the Supreme Court's order of 3 October 2023 in the Sandeep Grover matter dismissed the statutory appeals without reasons.

¶ 2.10, 25

The complainants filed complaints before MahaRERA. By common order dated 31 July 2025, the Authority directed that the project registration be kept in abeyance, restrained the new developer from advertising or transacting, and ordered status quo until the Arbitral, Court and other proceedings were finally determined, without deciding the merits.

¶ 2.12–2.14

The Appellate Tribunal set aside that order on 6 January 2026, holding that the complainants had no privity with the Society and could not enforce remedies against the Society or new developer.

¶ 2.16–2.17

The complainants then filed these second appeals.

¶ 2.18

02Issues

i.1. Whether, in view of the RERA, 2016 (Sections 15 and 18), third-party allottees of an erstwhile developer can enforce substantive rights against the Society after termination of the development agreement, notwithstanding the Vaidehi Akash line of decisions.

¶ 4–5 · ¶ 17

ii.2. Whether the Supreme Court's non-reasoned order in Sandeep Grover (3 October 2023), passed in a statutory appeal, attracts the doctrine of merger and overrules or binds the Tribunal away from the Vaidehi Akash line.

¶ 6–8 · ¶ 27–40

iii.3. Whether the Appellate Tribunal erred in deciding the merits without addressing the Authority's reasons for abeyance and status quo.

¶ 9 · ¶ 43

iv.4. Whether any substantial question of law arises for consideration under the second appeals.

¶ 44

03Law Applied

Section 15(1) of RERA restricts assignment of the promoter's rights without allottee consent and Authority approval, and Section 18 of RERA confers remedies on allottees against the promoter for default.

¶ 5

The line of Single Judge and Division Bench decisions in Vaidehi Akash Housing Pvt. Ltd. v. New D.N. Nagar CHS Union Ltd. and Goregaon Pearl CHSL v. Dr. Seema Mahadev Paryekar holds that third-party purchasers have no privity of contract with the Society and no enforceable rights against the Society or its assets after termination of the development agreement.

¶ 17–22

The reasoning of the Vaidehi Akash line was reaffirmed in Deepak Prabhakar Thakoor (WP (L) No. 1776 of 2023) and Kapilkunj CHS v. State of Maharashtra.

¶ 17–22

Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala distinguishes statutory appeals from Article 136 dismissals and notes that a speaking order alone creates a declaration of law.

¶ 29

Khoday Distilleries applies on the doctrine of merger.

¶ 30

Pernod Ricard holds that merger applies to a non-speaking dismissal of a statutory appeal.

¶ 31–32

Experion Developers v. Himanshu Dewan holds that a non-reasoned dismissal confined to its facts does not create a binding precedent under Article 141, though it may operate as res judicata between the parties.

¶ 33–36

The Authority was bound to follow the law declared by this Court under Kapilkunj.

¶ 21 · ¶ 42

Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9Section 17

Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. Section 15Section 18Section 19

04Reasoning

The Vaidehi Akash line, reaffirmed by Division Bench authority binding on MahaRERA, governs the rights of third-party purchasers against a Society after termination. The argument that RERA's Sections 15 and 18 displaced this line was rejected.

¶ 17–22

The Division Bench in Goregaon Pearl had already considered RERA's provisions and held that they do not impose liability on the landowner or Society for the developer's obligations.

¶ 20

Applying the Experion test, the NCDRC order affirmed by a non-reasoned Supreme Court dismissal of statutory appeals may bind the parties as res judicata or attract merger, but it lays down no law under Article 141.

¶ 35–36, 39–40

The Sandeep Grover decision turned on its own facts, in which the Society had taken possession of developer's flats and allotted them to its members. The present facts differ materially, including the developer's abandonment, default in transit rent and more than a decade of delay.

¶ 24 · ¶ 37 · ¶ 38

Keeping the project in abeyance until all litigation ended would make members' redevelopment hinge on litigation, "add insult to injury," and was unsustainable where the complainants had remedies against the erstwhile developer.

¶ 42

Because the foundation of the Authority's order failed, the Tribunal did not need to address the Authority's reasons separately.

¶ 43

05Holding

Issue 1 is answered against the complainants: third-party purchasers from the erstwhile developer cannot enforce substantive rights against the Society or its assets, and their remedy lies against the erstwhile developer.

¶ 22, 42

Issue 2 is answered in the negative: the non-reasoned Supreme Court order in Sandeep Grover lays down no law that overrules the Vaidehi Akash line, and the Tribunal was not disregarding a binding Supreme Court precedent.

¶ 39–41

Issue 3 is held against the complainants, as the Authority's order was legally unsustainable.

¶ 43

It is held that no substantial question of law arises.

¶ 44

The Second Appeals are dismissed, the interim applications, if any, are disposed of, and there is no order as to costs.

¶ 45
Bombay High Court

Original Court PDF

Afzal Alarakha MansurivsChembur Shivmurti Co Operative Housing Society Through Its Secretary Mr. Vijay C.Sharma

Bombay High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment