Supreme CourtFamily LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Father Kept Son Four Months After Taking Him From School; Supreme Court Refuses Abrupt Handover to Mother, Orders Counselling

Poornima Guptav.Saurav Gupta

Father Kept Son Four Months After Taking Him From School; Supreme Court Refuses Abrupt Handover to Mother, Orders Counselling. Poornima Gupta vs Saurav Gupta. Supreme Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the respondent-father is in contempt of this Court's order dated 12 December 2025 by retaining the minor son beyond his visitation rights and refusing to restore custody to the mother.

The court held

The Court prima facie held that the respondent-father is in clear contempt of the 12 December 2025 order, which vested custody in the mother with limited visitation for the father. It declined to order abrupt restoration of custody, finding the child's expressed wish unreliable due to apparent parental influence.

It also directed

Directions issued: (i) the Dholpur Family Court is to engage a child counsellor forthwith, with sessions initially held twice weekly in a separate room in an influence-free setting; (ii) the father must produce the child for sessions, must not interfere, and must bear the counsellor's expenses; (iii) the child may reside at Dholpur until the counsellor's report; (iv) the sealed report is to be placed before the Court on 22 January 2027, with a provision for earlier listing if the counsellor finds the child ready to return to the mother; and (v) the matter is listed on 22 January 2027 at 1:00 p.m. in chambers. The contempt finding is prima facie only, and no final punishment has been imposed in this order.

01Facts

The parties, spouses, were litigating Suit No. 149 of 2024 before the Family Court, Dholpur, Rajasthan, and the petitioner-mother sought its transfer to Delhi by Transfer Petition (C) No. 235 of 2025.

¶ 2

During mediation, the parties executed a settlement dated 13 November 2025, recorded by this Court's order dated 12 December 2025.

¶ 3

Under clause 3, the two children, Ms. P (then 11) and Master S (then 6), were to remain in the mother's custody, and the father was granted visitation to take them to Dholpur twice a year for four days each.

¶ 3

Under clause 5, the father agreed to pay Rs. 8,000 per month for the children's educational expenses until they become gainfully employed or marry; the mother claimed no maintenance.

¶ 4–5

Clause 10 barred the father from claiming custody otherwise than under the settlement.

¶ 5

On 22 July 2026, the father allegedly removed Master S from his school in Delhi and took him to Rajasthan, retaining him thereafter.

¶ 6

A police complaint produced no action.

¶ 7

Following a contempt notice and exchange of messages, the mother filed the present contempt petition.

¶ 8

Notice issued on 28 September 2026, and the child was produced in Court on 12 October 2026.

¶ 9–10

The father's counter-affidavit did not deny non-compliance but justified retention on the child's stated wish to remain with him, his close bond with the father, and alleged trauma caused by the maternal family; it also stated the child was admitted to a school in Dholpur.

¶ 11

In chambers on 3 November 2026, the Court found the child's mind appeared "severely tutored" against the mother and sister and that he refused to return to the mother.

¶ 12

The Court prima facie observed signs of substance abuse in the father.

¶ 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the respondent-father is in contempt of this Court's order dated 12 December 2025 by retaining the minor son beyond his visitation rights and refusing to restore custody to the mother.

¶ 14

ii.2. Whether the child's expressed wish and alleged bond with the father justify his continued retention.

¶ 11–12

iii.3. Whether the child's custody should be restored abruptly to the mother, or whether counselling should precede any restoration to protect the child's welfare.

¶ 14–15, 17–18

03Law Applied

The order rests on the terms of the 12 December 2025 order, which incorporated the parties' settlement: clause 3 (custody with the mother, visitation with the father), clause 5 (educational support), and clause 10 (no custody claim outside the settlement).

¶ 5–6, 14

The Court treated non-compliance with its own order as contempt, reflecting its power to enforce its orders, though the order does not identify the specific constitutional or statutory source of that power, beyond the matter being styled as an "inherent jurisdiction" proceeding.

The decision also applies the child's welfare as the governing consideration, stating that abrupt restoration could cause "permanent scar" on the child's psychology and that continued dislocation would lead to "sibling alienation".

¶ 14 · ¶ 15

No statutes or precedents are cited in the order.

04Reasoning

The Court accepted that the father did not deny retaining the child contrary to the settlement, so non-compliance was established on the father's own pleadings.

¶ 11

Although the father relied on the child's wishes and bond, the Court found the child's stated preference likely the product of influence, given that the child was "severely tutored" against the mother and sister and had been retained for about four months. The Court therefore treated the child's expressed wish as unreliable, weighing it against the father's conduct and the settlement's terms.

¶ 12, 14

Because the Court considered abrupt restoration potentially harmful to the child, it did not order immediate return. Instead it directed child counselling at the Dholpur Family Court, with the aim of restoring the child's trust in his mother and sister, and placed the expenses on the father. The child may remain at Dholpur pending the counsellor's report.

¶ 15–17

The Court framed the counselling as a protective, transitional step rather than a finding that the father's retention was lawful, leaving the contempt question open pending the report.

¶ 14 · ¶ 18

05Holding

The Court prima facie held that the respondent-father is in clear contempt of the 12 December 2025 order, which vested custody in the mother with limited visitation for the father. It declined to order abrupt restoration of custody, finding the child's expressed wish unreliable due to apparent parental influence.

¶ 12, 14

Directions issued: (i) the Dholpur Family Court is to engage a child counsellor forthwith, with sessions initially held twice weekly in a separate room in an influence-free setting; (ii) the father must produce the child for sessions, must not interfere, and must bear the counsellor's expenses; (iii) the child may reside at Dholpur until the counsellor's report; (iv) the sealed report is to be placed before the Court on 22 January 2027, with a provision for earlier listing if the counsellor finds the child ready to return to the mother; and (v) the matter is listed on 22 January 2027 at 1:00 p.m. in chambers. The contempt finding is prima facie only, and no final punishment has been imposed in this order.

¶ 14–19
Supreme Court

Original Court PDF

Poornima GuptavsSaurav Gupta

Supreme Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment