01Facts
The Petitioner, Helena Anna Maria Lersch, is a German citizen employed as Vice President of Public Policy at TikTok and based in Singapore.
¶ 6-8, 10The Respondent father, Suhaan Mukerji, is an Indian lawyer practising in New Delhi. The parties are unmarried.
¶ 6-8, 10Their son, Marcus Johannes Mukerji, was born on 15.07.2022 in New Delhi and holds a German passport.
¶ 6-8, 10The child lived with both parents across Delhi, Goa, Germany and, from February 2026, Kolkata. The child was out of formal schooling for several months.
¶ 8, 80In November 2025 the father returned the child from Germany to India, and in December 2025 the parties explored admission to UWCSEA, Singapore.
¶ 10-11The father withdrew consent by email on 04.02.2026.
¶ 10-11Following a dispute, the father took the child to Kolkata in February 2026 despite the mother's objection, and the mother filed a habeas corpus petition before the Bombay High Court (Goa Bench) on 17.02.2026.
¶ 12-14The High Court granted interim access.
¶ 12-14Thereafter, the father filed a guardianship petition before the District Judge, South 24-Parganas (Alipore) in April 2026 and obtained an ex parte restraint order.
¶ 15-16The mother alleged a six-week communication blackout (16.04.2026-25.05.2026) and continued obstruction.
¶ 17-22By order dated 11.08.2026, this Court referred the parties and child to NIMHANS for individual and family assessments.
¶ 28-29The guardianship petition was transferred to the Family Court, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi, with the parties' consent.
¶ 31The Petitioner was described by NIMHANS as having no diagnosable psychiatric disorder, and the father was similarly assessed.
¶ 84-8502Issues
i.1. Whether this Court has jurisdiction under Article 136 to decide interim custody of a minor in a habeas corpus proceeding originating before a High Court, when a guardianship petition is pending before a jurisdictional court.
¶ 3, 5, 125 (first conclusion)ii.2. Whether the subsequent filing of the guardianship petition renders the habeas corpus proceeding infructuous.
¶ 41-45iii.3. Whether the mother, as an unwed parent, has a better prima facie claim to interim custody.
¶ 65-68iv.4. Whether the balance of convenience favours the mother.
¶ 69-73v.5. Whether the child is likely to suffer irreparable harm if interim custody is not granted to the mother.
¶ 74-124vi.6. Whether the mother may take the child to Singapore, and on what safeguards.
¶ 127-133vii.7. Whether the habeas corpus petition should be transferred to this Court under Article 142.
¶ 13403Law Applied
The Court relied on the parens patriae jurisdiction of constitutional courts, which is inherent and independent of statute, exercised in habeas corpus proceedings for minors.
¶ 46, citing Rajeswari Chandrasekar Ganesh v. State of T.N.The welfare of the child is paramount and overrides procedural and jurisdictional objections, including international jurisdictional issues.
¶ 51-54, citing Gaurav Nagpal, Nil Ratan Kundu, Tejaswini Gaud, Vasudha Sethi, Sheetal Vasant ThakurCustody orders are interlocutory and alterable.
¶ 59-60, citing Neethu v. Rajesh KumarInterim relief is assessed on the triple test of prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable harm, viewed through the child's interests.
¶ 63-64, 74-75Under X1 v. State (NCT of Delhi), the mother has primary custodial rights over a child born outside wedlock, though the father's claim is not excluded.
¶ 66-68Section 17 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 and Section 12 (interim custody) were noted.
¶ 38, 50The applicability of Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 was disputed and not decided.
¶ 33, 38, 65Infructuousness principles from M. Sudakar and Nirmala v. Kulwant Singh require case-specific assessment.
¶ 43-45Protective "mirror orders" in transnational custody disputes follow Smriti Madan Kansagra.
¶ 128Article 142 is available to transfer proceedings to avoid duplication.
¶ 134Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 Section 12Section 13Section 17
Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 Section 6
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 1626
Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 8
04Reasoning
The guardianship petition seeks final adjudication, whereas the habeas corpus proceeding seeks only interim relief, so the two are distinct and the latter is not rendered infructuous.
¶ 42, 47-49Given the parents' total lack of cooperation and the risk of multiple proceedings harming a four-year-old, the Court exercised parens patriae jurisdiction to decide interim custody without displacing the Family Court.
¶ 50, 56, 61On prima facie claim, the Court found that the mother's preferential position for a very young child, reinforced by comparative jurisprudence, supports her claim.
¶ 68On balance of convenience, the mother had maintained consistent contact through litigation, and the father, a Delhi lawyer with resources and legal capacity, would face less inconvenience in travelling to Singapore.
¶ 69-73On irreparable harm, the Court viewed harm from the child's perspective. The NIMHANS report showed equal parental capacity, but the child's fluency in German and close bond with the mother, together with research on maternal separation, weighed in her favour.
¶ 83-96The Court rejected the father's rootedness argument, noting the child's multi-city upbringing and adaptability, and rejected the mental-health allegations as unsupported by NIMHANS.
¶ 109-116The Court found that the mother presented a concrete, proactive schooling plan with school correspondence and financial commitment, whereas the father's plan was unspecific and unsupported by documents. His work commitments raised concerns about delegating caregiving to others.
¶ 117-124To address the father's apprehension of non-cooperation once the child is outside India, the Court imposed safeguards: a Singapore mirror order, a ₹1 crore fixed deposit, a detailed parenting plan with daily video access and periodic Indian visits, and six-monthly psychological reports to prevent parental alienation.
¶ 127-13305Holding
The Court held that (i) it has jurisdiction to decide interim custody in exercise of parens patriae jurisdiction in the habeas corpus proceeding; (ii) the mother has a better prima facie claim; (iii) the balance of convenience favours the mother; and (iv) the child is likely to suffer irreparable injury if interim custody is denied to her.
¶ 125The habeas corpus petition (Writ Petition No. 478 of 2026(F), High Court of Bombay at Goa) was transferred to this Court under Article 142.
¶ 134Interim directions were issued: the mother must obtain a Singapore mirror order within three weeks; deposit ₹1 crore in the Registry; enrol the child in UWCSEA or a backup school; ensure daily father access by video (minimum 20 minutes); allow the father visits and school-vacation access in India; and obtain six-monthly psychological reports.
¶ A · ¶ 133 · ¶ E · ¶ H · ¶ I-M · ¶ PPending the mirror order, the weekly schedule in Delhi applies. Both parents must file undertakings within one week.
¶ B-C · ¶ QThe order is interim and does not bind the Family Court, Patiala House Courts, which will decide Guardianship Petition No. 37 of 2026 finally. The matter is listed for 7 December 2026.
¶ 135 · ¶ 136Original Court PDF
Helena Anna Maria LerschvsState Of Goa
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
